What Their Records Really Should Read?

[Perfect Plex]

Right, post what you feel should be fighters REAL record but isn't and give reason behind your pick.

I'll start.

Pernell Whitaker's Real Record.
42-3-0
Should of won against Ramirez 1st time and defeated Chavez.

Oscar De La Hoya Real Record
41-5-0.
I feel he defeated Trinidad & Mosley the second time, but lost the Strum, & Mayweather fights. I also felt he won the Quartey fight

[CantBeTouched]

Manny Pacquiao

51-6

Lost to Torrecampo, Singsurat, Morales, Marquez twice, and also did not deserve a draw against Agapito Sanchez

[Dunkeroo23]

Hopkins

54-3-1

beat calzaghe, split with taylor, beat pascal

Marquez

JMM

57-1: only true loss was to Mayweather

Pacquiao

51-6: loss both to marquez

[Spray_resistant]

Mayweather should have 1 Loss the first castillo Fight

JMM should have only 1 loss vs Mayweather

and Lucian Bute should have 1 Loss vs Andrade

Can't agree more about the Andrade/Bute fight, he legitimately tko'd him no unbiased ref would have not made him step forward at which time he would have stumbled and it would have been waved off.

[LeG00N]

Marquez has one real loss

Mayweather 40-1

[AssasinKing]

Literally just watched Mayweather vs Castillo 1 for the first time

May should have 1 loss (minimum) on his record...

I had it 114-112 to Castillo....I dont know where the judges got the scores 115-111, 115-111 and 116-111

[BostonGuy]

Vitali Klitschko- 44-0....

[Perfect Plex]

I feel Andre Dirrel should be 20-0.

[Rocky Rode]

Marquez has one real loss

Mayweather 40-1

Chris John gave Marquez a boxing lesson.

[TintaBoricua]

Chris John gave Marquez a boxing lesson.

I could see people trying to make a case for JMM's fights with Pacquiao and Chris John, but c'mon...

He was beat by Freddie Norwood...this was a young JMM, BTW.

He was also disqualified in his pro debut. Let's give a pass for that, but you CANNOT discredit Norwood. It's not like the judges robbed Marquez or anything.