Mexicans, is JM Márquez in your Top 20 Mexican boxers ever?

[-Huey-]

chiquita gonzalez and carabajal>>> JMM true story......

JMM can MAYBE crack top 30 but not Top 20

Chiquita Gonzalez better than JMM?? Log off now and join shitsideboxing.com

[Dustaine]

Oh no,

And Carbajal is a Mexican-American, technically he goes down as an American fighter not Mexican. Are you counting those as well?

Like I said bro, you can name every single Mexican fighter you want just for the sake of naming them. But, you can't name 20 who have a greater resume/accomplishments than JMM.

Rosales, I'll tell you ThrowedEssay's problem. The problem is here, in this thread about Gamboa vs Rafa Márquez. He said the following about Gamboa:

dude salido is our weakest champ and ur boy (Gamboa) couldn't stop him

I answered:

He (Salido) whooped Guerrero's ass, and JMM, one Mexico's best ever, couldn't stop Salido either.

And he said:

the guerreo fight was ruled a no contest....

and LMAO at JMM being 1 of Mexico's best ever hahahahahah he is 1 of the best of this era but not even close to top 20 in Mexico's ATG's.......

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10441466#post10441466

Now he's pretty angry that I opened this thread, and no one agrees with him.

[The Gambler1981]

Are we talking just pure blooded Mexican who were born and raised in Mexico or we talking just any dude with some Mexican blood flowing through their veins.

[sdcluser]

JMM is overrated by dumb fans like you who think just cuz you seen his fights, you under estimate all the Mexican Fighters who fought 15 rounds and beat the likes of henry armstrong.... vicente saldivar, mando ramos, pipino cuevas to name a few

JMM is not in the same level as vicente saldivar or mando ramos?
JMM can go 15 rds.

The fights that JMM lost have been only ELITE fighters. And some of
these lost is highly controversial.
In terms of boxing IQ, JMM is among the top in Mexican fighters.

[Dustaine]

Gamboa still ain **** though

[jrosales13]

look up all the mexicans in the hall of fame ****** i'm not posting all the names who could be arguably better then him

Why can't you do it? You the one who's saying there tons who are greater. So you would think it would be easy for you to name 20

Of the top of my head. You have Zarate, Cuevas, JCC, Sanchez, Olivares, Gonzalez, Palomino, Canto, Zaragosa, Saldivar, Arizmendi, Lopez.

That's 11 out of the top of my head. Who's missing? Who am I not counting?

I mean where the other 9 at?

I'm pretty sure I'm missing a couple HOF Mexican fighters who has slipped my mind. But, I doubt is 9 of them.

And, what does it matter anyways? JMM would be in the HOF as well? So again who are these 20-29 who are greater?

[jrosales13]

JMM's siganture wins are what barrera and casamayor?? man please he isn't even better then barrera

OK he's not greater than Barrera and? Is Barrera not easily top 20? Arguably top 10 as well?

[jrosales13]

his win over carabajal and even in he's loss to him>>> JMM's entire career!

You're just being ridiculous.

[Dustaine]

even robert garcia said he would beat gamboa LMAO

Wow, he said it!

[jrosales13]

please don't ever say barrera is near top 10

Of course he is, he's arguably a top 10 great Mexican. Again you can name every single Mexican fighter you want. But, it would be debatable to name 10 Mexican fighters who have a greater resume/accomplishments than Barrera.