How would welterweight look without pac or floyd?

[MRBOOMER]

Well with them two out and clottey going to 145 and cotto already their and so is margo. New people would come in

So it would be like.
1. ORTIZ
2. BERTO
3. SHANE
4. BRADLEY
5. ALEXZANDER/ mallinagi

I say those last two cause Bradley had one fight their and would prbly go up after a fight with khan for bigger fights.
And alexander because I think 147 would be better for his style. Plus the names are up their.

[The Gambler1981]

I think cotto wouldn't have moved to 154 had he not been beaten by pac maybe defend his title when he had to plus a few catchweight fights closer to 154. I also think clottey beats this past prime version of mosley as well as berto. I know there are several other variables but i'm assuming floyd and pac didn't fight at 147.

If they never existed sure you could be right.

It would have come down to a rematch between Cotto and Mosley to decide number 1 assuming Margarito fell off in the same fashion.

Plus what about Paul Williams I think he could have lingered longer at 147 especially if he had a shot to be the man there which looking at that list I would have to give Williams at least a sporting chance.

I don't think Clottey has it in him to win a big fight so I feel he finds a way to lose to Mosley or he doesn't even end up in that fight because he doesn't have the pull to get it.

1 winner Cotto/Mosley rematch
2 Williams
3 Ortiz
4 loser Cotto/Mosley rematch
5 Clottey/Berto I think you could make a case for both guys.

[01samuelc]

Isn't Cotto at 154 now? I guess he could come back if the division looked like that but why really and what has Clottey done to even warrant a top 5 ranking he has not fought in over a year.


Pretty much the division looks like open ass.

If pressed I would go
1 vacant
2 Ortiz
3 Mosley
4 Senchenko (I like him a bit more than Zaveck)
5 Berto

I think cotto wouldn't have moved to 154 had he not been beaten by pac maybe defend his title when he had to plus a few catchweight fights closer to 154. I also think clottey beats this past prime version of mosley as well as berto. I know there are several other variables but i'm assuming floyd and pac didn't fight at 147.

[The Gambler1981]

Isn't Cotto at 154 now? I guess he could come back if the division looked like that but why really and what has Clottey done to even warrant a top 5 ranking he has not fought in over a year.


Pretty much the division looks like open ass.

If pressed I would go
1 vacant
2 Ortiz
3 Mosley
4 Senchenko (I like him a bit more than Zaveck)
5 Berto

[01samuelc]

How do you think the top 5 would look like?
IMO
1) Cotto
2)Clottey
3)Mosley
4)Ortiz
5)Berto