Would Manny Pacquiao go through Floyd Mayweather's resume undefeated?

[bojangles1987]

I think Pac loses to Corrales and Castillo at the TIME FLOYD FOUGHT THEM. I also think there's a pretty good chance Pac loses to DLH at 154 when Floyd fought him.

Are you judging this based on the year and how Pac was that year, or Pac at that weight against those guys at their weight? You can only seriously judge it based on Pacquiao at that weight and assuming Mayweather's opponents were in the same position as when Mayweather fought them. Of course Pacquiao would lose to Castillo in 2002 when Mayweather fought him, Pacquiao was at 122.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

P4P wise Floyd would beat everyone on Pacs resume with no issues.

[KingOfBox]

Judah in his prime would have been interesting against Manny... 2 southpaws... But Manny would still win...Ndou vs Manny would've been cool too

[educator06]

deiego corrales would put pacman to sleep

[Larry the boss]

P4P wise Floyd would beat everyone on Pacs resume with no issues.

true..he def wouldve lost to surgaut and torrecampo

[Slick_Rick]

Possibly, if you're referring to the 2005 Manny and beyond. 135 and above he beats them all, and not just beats them, i seriously believe he would TKO/KO every fighter Floyd has faced, bar De La Hoya.

.

[AssasinKing]

Yes and No.

Depends what version of Manny Pacquiao you're referring to.
Pacquiao of today can basically run through anyone's resume undefeated within reasonable weight including Floyd's.

You take who Floyd was fighting at age 27 and take an age 27 version of Pacquiao and Manny gets his tail whooped a few times in my opinion.

Thats what im saying

People should just talk about prime for prime....if they really wanna debate these 2

[Pacquiao'd]

a better question is...

would Floyd Mayweather Jr go through Manny Pacquiao's resume undefeated?

with EASE...........

[daggum]

Judah in his prime would have been interesting against Manny... 2 southpaws... But Manny would still win...Ndou vs Manny would've been cool too

you probably think that was a great win for floyd. ndou was 32-1 with 31 knockouts holy shi-ttttttttttttttt incredible victory! just look at his record he must be good...

[Horvo]

There are certain parts that you simply can't compare. Does PBF lose to Torrecampo in 96 or Singsurat in 99? Of course he does because there is no way he can come close to making 112 at that time. He would have had to fight them when he was 13.