Would Manny Pacquiao go through Floyd Mayweather's resume undefeated?

[Jsmooth9876]

Floyd lost that first fight to Castillo anyways so who cares. Same as all the people who say Marquez beat Manny multiple times.

[-Kev-]

Lol well this is pretty old but Marquez proved the answer is no, he can not.

[-Kev-]

who the fuck has Floyd beaten that Pac at his peak wouldn't beat?

Pac would never fight DLH and Cotto at 154 and Canelo at 152. Ever. He'd be too scared and want some kind of advantage, despite being the same size as Floyd on FN.

[Jewel]

Lol well this is pretty old but Marquez proved the answer is no, he can not.

four fights?...

[Jsmooth9876]

Pac would never fight DLH and Cotto at 154 and Canelo at 152. Ever. He'd be too scared and want some kind of advantage, despite being the same size as Floyd on FN.

Lol...you're delusional if you think those first two make a difference..then u talk about advantages and yet Floyd fights the young tough kid at 152 instead of 154 where he fought the first 2 you mentioned. You Floyd lovers are the most hypocritical posters around.

[-Kev-]

I don't see it at all, Pacquiao wouldn't have kept Oscar off of him, Oscar likely stops him. Canelo would have caught Pacquiao coming in, he has all the tools and on top of that a considerable size advantage. Marquez, well we know how that usually goes. Also, Castillo would have tested Pacquiao on the inside, cut the ring off on him and he'd have the chin to compete. Genaro Hernandez would have been problematic as well. Again I don't see it, Pacquiao isn't big enough for the most part to do it.

I honestly think Pacquiao would have knocked out Hernandez, Castillo and Corrales at 130-135 if they fought that version of Pacquiao that was around in those weight classes. I believe the Pac that fought David Diaz(as weak as he was) would have KO'ed the Castillo that fought Mayweather.

Pac would have destroyed Jesus Chavez, bad style match up for Chavez. Judah, Gatti, Burton, Manfredy, Sosa would have all been beaten to a pulp. Guerrero and Ortiz may be competitive but they lose as well. Baldomir would have been stopped, again, bad style match up. We saw what happened to Cotto and Hatton.

One thing I will give you is that a full JMW healthy DLH with the rehydration he had vs Mayweather at 154 wouldn't have been an easy fight. Neither would Canelo at 152, or even Cotto at the full 154 limit. Marquez obviously is never an easy fight for Pac. For some reason I just see DeMarcus Corley(prime 2 losses) having some kind of success vs Pacquiao, but losing.

[-Kev-]

Lol...you're delusional if you think those first two make a difference..then u talk about advantages and yet Floyd fights the young tough kid at 152 instead of 154 where he fought the first 2 you mentioned. You Floyd lovers are the most hypocritical posters around.

DLH fought Floyd at 154, and rehydrated to who knows what, probably 160+. DLH fought Pac at 146 and DLH came in to the ring at 147lbs, rehydrating 1lb. If you think an Oscar that weighs 160+ on fight night would not better than an Oscar who weighed 147lbs on fight night, you are the delusional one.

Floyd fought Canelo at 152 but make no mistake, Pacquiao would never even fight anelo at 150lbs, he would ask him to come down below 150lbs or he wouldn't fight him. He would not fight Yuri Foreman, forget Canelo. Pac tried to get a rematch with Cotto below 150lbs again.

[littlemac]

Pac would never fight DLH and Cotto at 154 and Canelo at 152. Ever. He'd be too scared and want some kind of advantage, despite being the same size as Floyd on FN.

This right here.

Pac's resume would be a walk in a park for Floyd.

[Jsmooth9876]

DLH fought Floyd at 154, and rehydrated to who knows what, probably 160+. DLH fought Pac at 146 and DLH came in to the ring at 147lbs, rehydrating 1lb. If you think an Oscar that weighs 160+ on fight night would not better than an Oscar who weighed 147lbs on fight night, you are the delusional one.

Floyd fought Canelo at 152 but make no mistake, Pacquiao would never even fight anelo at 150lbs, he would ask him to come down below 150lbs or he wouldn't fight him. He would not fight Yuri Foreman, forget Canelo. Pac tried to get a rematch with Cotto below 150lbs again.

Oscar was shot regardless. He had lost to Sturm and got the bogus decision then got KO by BHOP. Beat R Mayorga lol..... The speed of Manny was to much for Oscar and it wouldn't have mattered at 154 at that point in his career.

So because Manny wouldn't fight above 150 where he maxed out, Floyd gets a pass because of it lol...Floyd had fought two aged guys at 154 and made a huge deal of it ." I fight guys where they're comfortable" remember? Then makes the young tough guy drop the extra 2 lbs...the kid can't even make 154 it seems, never mind getting to 152.

So you're saying Manny fuc**ng Pacquiao ducked Yuri Foreman? Come on, now you're just being ****** to try to make your point.

Manny hasn't and won't fight over 150 after the Margarito fight, he's said it and hasn't since.

[face untouched]

**** outta here wit yo dumbass thread he already got put to sleep by Marquez and what the hell do you think a fully weight Oscar and Cotto do to his ass? Pac took multilple L's against cab drivers from the pilippines what d o you think happens in the US?