Hopkins Calzaghe who won

[RubenSonny]

Draw option should be available, I've seen the fight once and I thought Hopkins won but I'm not mad at anyone thinking Calzaghe won.

[ATG Fighter]

I judge entirely by punch out-put and crowd reaction. Those are the only things that matter in boxing.

I also had oscar de la hoya beating floyd 10 rounds to 2, Alexander beating Timothy Bradley and Hatton was well ahead on the scorecards prior to getting KO'd by floyd.

These are HARD FACTS. Undebatable.

I figured out a full proof formula:

Crowd Reaction = R
Punch Output = P

P X R = Winning

I like to go by what HBO says. They have absolutely no agenda and can be trusted. So I just go by what Harold Lederman says.

[King Ghidorah]

how did this topic explode so much?
did Bsrizpac initiate it or Ghidora?
and where Soir? he'd love this :laugh:

I remeber Bsrizpac from the UG..... But I thought he was banned here?...

[ИATAS]

I like to go by what HBO says. They have absolutely no agenda and can be trusted. So I just go by what Harold Lederman says.

Yes, that is also just as good. If they tell you a punch landed, and the replay shows it actually didn't, it in fact landed because they said so. It overrules instant replay. Easily.

Compubox is another bullet proof system.

Alexander threw and landed more punches against Bradley = Alexander won. Not even debatable.

[MARKBNLV]

Draw option should be available, I've seen the fight once and I thought Hopkins won but I'm not mad at anyone thinking Calzaghe won.

Thats not absurd at all there were a few toss up rds.

[daggum]

I judge entirely by punch out-put and crowd reaction. Those are the only things that matter in boxing.

I also had oscar de la hoya beating floyd 10 rounds to 2, Alexander beating Timothy Bradley and Hatton was well ahead on the scorecards prior to getting KO'd by floyd.

These are HARD FACTS. Undebatable.

I figured out a full proof formula:

Crowd Reaction = R
Punch Output = P

P X R = Winning

i like your system. it doesn't follow any of the rules of boxing but i'm a rebel so i refuse to score based on clean punching and the like. that stuff is nonsense. i would also add what the commentators are saying into my system. HARD LEFT HAND BY CALZAGHE! even though i just saw him hit hopkins glove but he must have landed it. thanks jim!

[Lead Cenobite]

i like your system. it doesn't follow any of the rules of boxing but i'm a rebel so i refuse to score based on clean punching and the like. that stuff is nonsense. i would also add what the commentators are saying into my system. HARD LEFT HAND BY CALZAGHE! even though i just saw him hit hopkins glove but he must have landed it. thanks jim!

Sadly as funny as his post was A LOT OF POSTERS GO BY THIS as a judging criteria. Scary ****.

[Jack Napier]

I remeber Bsrizpac from the UG..... But I thought he was banned here?...

he was, but he's still here
nobody here actually leaves when they're banned
he has the Pinhead avatar

[daggum]

Yes, that is also just as good. If they tell you a punch landed, and the replay shows it actually didn't, it in fact landed because they said so. It overrules instant replay. Easily.

Compubox is another bullet proof system.

Alexander threw and landed more punches against Bradley = Alexander won. Not even debatable.

enzo calzaghe threw his challenge flag and instituted compubox overrule in the hopkins-calzaghe fight.

[Lead Cenobite]

enzo calzaghe threw his challenge flag and instituted compubox overrule in the hopkins-calzaghe fight.

Things i"ve heard about the Joe fight:

Hopkins deserved to lose cause:

he faked low blows
he didnt throw as many punches as Joe
the fight was boring
hopkins made it a boring fight
hopkins is a racist
hopkins didnt push the pace/

Not ONE of these excuses has anything to do with scoring a fight.