Who has the BETTER RESUME? Floyd Jr. or Oscar De La Hoya?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Floyd and that's without being bias, Floyd run at 130 was remarkable, His win over Castillo at 135 is better than any win that Oscar has at 135. And, 135 is arguably where Oscar was at his best, is that safe to say?

I don't see how losses outweigh wins. Unless they're controversial losses. But, with Oscar he has more controversial wins than he does controversial losses. Does he not?

Honestly biased aside, and is funny that I have to say that because I'm not even a Floyd fan. But, I am actually flabbergasted that people think Oscar is greater than Floyd. I need somebody to explain to me how? Because, he fed on Tito leftovers? Because, he beat 2 great but old and past prime fighters and one of the wins was controversial? Or because, he won 6 titles in 6 divisions, one being controversial, and a couple others being paper titles.

did you vote for floyd?


because if you didnt, you're just posting a whole buncha lies jro.

[Pacquiao'd]

smh at anyone who says Oscar De la (i lost most of my big fights) Hoya

[shodown19]

As far as quality opponents. I have to give it to Oscar despite his losses. Pernell Whitaker, Fernando Vargas, arguably Trinidad and arguably prime Mosley are some great fights that you can't take away from him. Not to mention he's the only fighter that's ever won a scorecard against Mayweather.

Win or loss, not many people can say they've been in the ring with Bernard Hopkins, Floyd Mayweather and Manny Pacquiao.

But you have to respect the 0. People don't give Floyd enough credit for his wins.

[Turok2]

i wouldnt piss on him if he was on fire.


seriously.

lmfao...

[Left Hook Tua]

resume =wins

oscar lost most of his big fights

oscar has wins over oba carr , ike quartey , pernell whitaker , julio cesar chavez , hector camacho , rafael ruelas , john john molina , jesse james leija , genaro hernandez , fernando vargas......

let's not act like oscar lost every fight he had. he's had 6 losses BUT every single one of them were against guys who were #1 p4p.

and you can make a case that oscar won half of those fights. (the 2 with mosley and the one with tito)

[jrosales13]

You're putting jro on the spot, he knows the clear answer but I don't think he wants to vote for that person. Maybe you should of put the voting poll to anonymous. lol

Not really because, I make it clear that it's Floyd.

[Larry the boss]

oscar has wins over oba carr , ike quartey , pernell whitaker , julio cesar chavez , hector camacho , rafael ruelas , john john molina , jesse james leija , genaro hernandez , fernando vargas......

let's not act like oscar lost every fight he had. he's had 6 losses BUT every single one of them were against guys who were #1 p4p.

and you can make a case that oscar won half of those fights. (the 2 with mosley and the one with tito)

chavez,camacho,and whitaker were all past prime...and the whitaker fight was contraversal

[Russian Crushin]

oscar has wins over oba carr , ike quartey , pernell whitaker , julio cesar chavez , hector camacho , rafael ruelas , john john molina , jesse james leija , genaro hernandez , fernando vargas......

let's not act like oscar lost every fight he had. he's had 6 losses BUT every single one of them were against guys who were #1 p4p.

and you can make a case that oscar won half of those fights. (the 2 with mosley and the one with tito)

Exactly, Oscar only lost to the #1 P4P fighter of the time, with 2 of those should have been wins

But he also beat many great fighters, people seem to forget that

[Left Hook Tua]

chavez,camacho,and whitaker were all past prime...and the whitaker fight was contraversal

yeah because everyone floyd beat was in their prime.

[jrosales13]

oscar has wins over oba carr , ike quartey , pernell whitaker , julio cesar chavez , hector camacho , rafael ruelas , john john molina , jesse james leija , genaro hernandez , fernando vargas......

let's not act like oscar lost every fight he had. he's had 6 losses BUT every single one of them were against guys who were #1 p4p.

and you can make a case that oscar won half of those fights. (the 2 with mosley and the one with tito)

You think a case can be made that he beat Mosley the first time?