There's a big 5 in boxing not just a big 4 imo

[The_Demon]

Id make it a top 6 and throw hopkins in there too,im not really a fan of the guy but he defies logic and gotta admire him

[baCCaT]

put marquez up..its ok..

just take down the inactive ones for chrissakes..

[$Bullsfam$]

i kinda agree with kellerman but not wih the ts......jmm has looked regular fighting katsidis....i'd put bute in the # 5 slot tho....

Seriously? Kasiditis is better then anybody Bute has ever fought. I'm not saying Michael beats them but compared to the people Bute's beat, Kasiditis is a monster compared to his resume. Get off Bute's ****, he's not that good. I love how he beats a shot out Edison Miranda and then people start saying he's the #1 super middleweight in the world.

I don't think Bute could beat anybody but Jermain Taylor from the Original super 6 but Taylor would probably be winning but gas and get dropped.

[mrgreenfingers]

i kinda agree with kellerman but not wih the ts......jmm has looked regular fighting katsidis....i'd put bute in the # 5 slot tho....

bute ahead of marquez lol

[Cassius Liston]

This weekend Max Kellerman mentioned that he thought Sergio Martinez, Floyd Mayweather Jr., Manny Pacquiao, and Nonito Donaire were a cut above the rest of the boxing world. Well, imo Juan Manuel Marquez belongs on that list, Marquez is special just like the other 4.

They also said that they meant athletically gifted.. as in really fast hands and feet... Jmm couldn't compete with floyd in the reflex dept.. you should listen more carefully next time...

[New England]

agreed.


marquez has done things that none of those guys can say they've done


his career's been on deaths door, mid-fight, more times than i can count
and the dude gets back up
and stops dudes in wars


there's nobody like him alive and fighting today

he's at least as great as anybody in the game in terms of the fights he produces.

[New England]

They also said that they meant athletically gifted.. as in really fast hands and feet... Jmm couldn't compete with floyd in the reflex dept.. you should listen more carefully next time...

marquez is a 37 year old featherweight



most guys his age and size are many years retired.



and in terms of gifts...
marquez might be the most accurate combination puncher in the game, and he's years beyond his physical prime



he's just a legendary fighter boxer.