Froch V Mayweather Jr - Who deserves to be in the p4p list?

[MOTHER DUCKER]

It's crazy i mean Segura over Froch.. among others?

If Floyd doesn't fight this year then sure.. but there is many other fighters Froch shud be in over

[Swag Hustla]

They both are.

Froch is one of best around today. Maybe not top 5 p4p, but definitely top 10.

I don't think anyone in boxing has a tougher list of previous opponents within the last 2 years.

Pascal W by UD
Taylor W by TKO 12
Dirrell W by SD (controversial, I know)
Kessler L by UD (could have gone either way, i thought Froch it)
Abraham W by UD

Floyd still deserves to be #2 since the Mosley fight was only nine months ago. If Floyd doesn't fight or at least announce a fight within a few months, he should be dropped.

[Marchegiano]

wow, the enemy of your enemy is your friend huh? Idioto's Floyd wins this just in past meritorious achievement. What the **** has Froch done? Who the **** is that? ( exaggeration I do know the Cobra) Ricky Hatton all over again.

I have to add a little bit to every pro-Floyd post I make. There's always some Pacquaio fan just waiting to tell me how ****** I am when I brag on Floyd. Even if there's nothing directly involving Manny it seems you can only be a fan of one. That's ****ing ******. So officially I like Floyd and Manny for 1 and 2 p4p but in no particular order as i'm unsure who's better than the other. However, as far as the rest of boxing goes it's position 3 or worse. I end up defending Floyd more than Manny because Manny fans are ****** and come out in masses.

[bojangles1987]

If Mayweather doesn't have plans for a fight to take place by the end of this year, he is off the list. I already have him off, and Froch definitely deserves a spot.

[SirTomJones]

Froch winning

[Earl-Hickey]

I like Mayweather, but his inactivity is a joke, you cant even call him a boxer because he doesnt box.

Froch should be top 10 p4p, but the ring don't like him for some reason, they'd probably prefer him if his last fi5 fights were something like

W UD Pascall
W TKO Paul Smith
W TKO Jesse Brinkley
W TKO Edison Miranda
W UD Arthur Abraham

he'd be top 5 then probably

[shade darkar]

im not a fan of carl froch, but surely i cant be on my own when i say, if carl froch is top ten p4p then boxing is wank at the moment. i have always rated carl froch as one of the worst title holders in the game today. but he has proven me wrong to some extent.

i no longer think he is one of the worst champions in the game today, i rate him as a worthy champion due to his will to face the best. seen as tho some of the other champions in the game like pacquiao, mayweather, haye, wlad etc etc not fighting the best, it makes you appreciate guys like froch a bit more. even if he isnt as talented.

but if i only rate him because of other guys failings to make decent fights, what does that say about boxing at the moment?

on topic, id say mayweather would take froch to school even if mayweather weighed in at 147 and froch at 168. the difference in skill is massive!

[Earl-Hickey]

im not a fan of carl froch, but surely i cant be on my own when i say, if carl froch is top ten p4p then boxing is wank at the moment. i have always rated carl froch as one of the worst title holders in the game today. but he has proven me wrong to some extent.

i no longer think he is one of the worst champions in the game today, i rate him as a worthy champion due to his will to face the best. seen as tho some of the other champions in the game like pacquiao, mayweather, haye, wlad etc etc not fighting the best, it makes you appreciate guys like froch a bit more. even if he isnt as talented.

but if i only rate him because of other guys failings to make decent fights, what does that say about boxing at the moment?

on topic, id say mayweather would take froch to school even if mayweather weighed in at 147 and froch at 168. the difference in skill is massive!

I doubt it, Mayweather got clocked by guys like Ricky Hatton enough times to make me belive that froch would land something and send Mayweathers head to the moon.

[shade darkar]

I doubt it, Mayweather got clocked by guys like Ricky Hatton enough times to make me belive that froch would land something and send Mayweathers head to the moon.

yeah its possible, but id doubt it would happen. froch struggled to hit dirrell also. if this fight was to happen id pick mayweather to win by outboxing him easily.