Where will Donaire land on the P4P list?

[Russian Crushin]

With his dominating performance over Montiel, where do you expect Donaire to land on the P4P list

Im a huge fan of Donaire but i say he stays at #5

I think talent wise he is # 3 but i just cant put him over JMM or Sergio with just that win

[Espada]

I'd put Donaire at #2 behind Pac. Montiel is a no joke and a solid 3 division champ.

Montiel has accomplished more than Paul Williams.

Darchinyan has a better resume than Pavlik.

[Pullcounter]

as of right now, he's better than jmm, but can't rank him any higher. martinez beat pavlik and pwill. wifebeater beat mosley and has never been beaten. pac is obviously #1. so nonito is #4.

[johncods]

1. Pac
2. Martinez
3. Donaire

[Swag Hustla]

#4:

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Martinez
4. Donaire
5. JMM

I can't put Donaire over Martinez, but I could rank him over Marquez. It wasn't too long ago when he was dropped to the bottom of the p4p list after Floyd beat him and a win over Katidis doesn't do much for me to rank him back in the top now that Donaire finally proved to everyone that he belongs on that list.

Montiel was a top 10 p4p fighter in his own right.

And Floyd is inactive, but it's not like he's officially retired, and his last fight was against #3 p4p ranked Mosley only 9 months ago.

[Russian Crushin]

as of right now, he's better than jmm, but can't rank him any higher. martinez beat pavlik and pwill. wifebeater beat mosley and has never been beaten. pac is obviously #1. so nonito is #4.

That's Fair

I just think JMM's resume keeps him at #4

[Bring It On]

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Donaire
4. JMM

[Espada]

Beating Darchinyan and Montiel is far more impressive than Martinez beating Williams and Pavlik.

[DARKSEID]

Beating Darchinyan and Montiel is far more impressive than Martinez beating Williams and Pavlik.

not only that- but donaire did it more impressively

i got him above martinez

[Russian Crushin]

Beating Darchinyan and Montiel is far more impressive than Martinez beating Williams and Pavlik.

IM not really sure how its "far more impressive". Maybe a little since he had brutal KOs in both