If Martinez Dominates 2011 like He Did 2010, Is He The Second Best Fighter P4P?

[Motofan]

If Pac keeps fighting bums, then Sergio becomes number 1 with another great year. Pac just keeps hurting his legacy each time he fights another "Bob approved" fighter at a "Bob approved" weight.

[Crazylegs77]

depends who he beats.

I dont see him facing a Pavlik and Williams back to back again, but its plausible.

Dzinziruk is not as accomplished as either of those two, so it would take a pretty huge win(s) at 154/160 to do as well as he did last year.

I agree with this

IMO he deserves the no. 1 spot if he has another good run this year and if Pac decides to keep fighting subpar opponents. I don't think it's likely though.

and good point

[Gino Ros]

Martinez is the best fighter P4P.

He called out the #1 ranked guy, and that guy peed down his leg and ran to fight an old man.

[Steak]

I dont see why Martinez or Pacquiao have to be the FOTY for this year. It could easily be the winner of Donaire-Montiel if that guy goes on to beat other good fighters...or maybe the winner of Bradley-Khan if that fight happens...perhaps Wladimir if he can beat Adamek and Haye this year. And dont forget about the winner of the super six, or perhaps Lucian Bute or someone.

the year is early, you dont know whats in store...I have a strong feeling that neither Pac nor Martinez will be FOTY in 2011.

[Heeb]

If Floyd doesn't fight this year he could be removed from the rankings and Sergio would be second p4p by default.

[simpson69]

No because that would mean he's on a side-meth or peds. The guy is 35 i mean who gets better at that age?

[Khalid X]

No.

Manny will face and destroy Berto or Bradley in the fall, retaining his P4P #1 Ranking.

Let's be real and realize that Martinez only has two great wins (Williams & Pavlik) in his entire career (three if he can beat Dzinziruk).

How that makes him P4P #1 right now is beyond me.