RND By RND ScoreCard only THREAD: Mayweather VS. Castillo I (TAKE A STAND)

[MXboxingfan]

@ Everybody who scored the fight for Castillo.

Try watching the fight with the volume turned off. That way you will not listen to Larry Merchant's commentary when watching the fight.

[cleaner147]

hey I wanted to join this party.

[QADASHBANYAH]

***** Rookie of the Year.

WHILE YOU CALL ME A ROOKIE, WHAT YOU FAIL TO UNDERSTAND IS THAT I am more than likely older than you, I have seen most of teh **** you watch live son, I exhibited that I could follow instructions, you still have not posted your opinions card wise w/ round for round analysis.

I think the point Horus is making is that many people will holler that Castillo was robbed, but they cant call a fight, or dont know what to look for. Hence you cant go into detail as to why with an analysis by yourself. Get specific TRICK.

Then you come and insult me because I guess I am talking about your heroe or something. Which makes you pretty gay.

I like floyd as a boxer, and thats it. I have my own life to live, instead of arguing with you simple keyboard warriors that are pretty much ****sexuals.......

May you have the balls to look at yourself in the mirror and try to make yourself a better man son.. UNTUCK YOUR NUTS AND GIRD THYSELF...

[PACnPBFsuck]

Mayweather ___ Castillo
1. 10 9
2. 10. 9
3. 9. 10
4. 10 9
5. 9 10
6. 9. 10
7. 9. 10
8. 10 8
9. 10. 9
10. 8. 10
11. 10. 9
12. 10. 9

114_112 Mayweather but easily could've gone either way

[sweetpea87]

Well I'm not posting a round by round scorecard, but I watched that fight about 4 years ago and remembering it being close and having it slightly for Castillo or a draw would have been good too. The official scorecards should have been closer even if the judges had Floyd winning. Floyd beat him hands down in the rematch.

[ИATAS]

WHILE YOU CALL ME A ROOKIE, WHAT YOU FAIL TO UNDERSTAND IS THAT I am more than likely older than you, I have seen most of teh **** you watch live son, I exhibited that I could follow instructions, you still have not posted your opinions card wise w/ round for round analysis.

I think the point Horus is making is that many people will holler that Castillo was robbed, but they cant call a fight, or dont know what to look for. Hence you cant go into detail as to why with an analysis by yourself. Get specific TRICK.

Then you come and insult me because I guess I am talking about your heroe or something. Which makes you pretty gay.

I like floyd as a boxer, and thats it. I have my own life to live, instead of arguing with you simple keyboard warriors that are pretty much ****sexuals.......

May you have the balls to look at yourself in the mirror and try to make yourself a better man son.. UNTUCK YOUR NUTS AND GIRD THYSELF...

woah slow down there geronimo. rookie means new, as in you're new to the site.

Welcome to boxingscene. Now relax, take a valium or something and enjoy the community.

[QADASHBANYAH]

woah slow down there geronimo. rookie means new, as in you're new to the site.

Welcome to boxingscene. Now relax, take a valium or something and enjoy the community.

Oh I definitely will, but I have been here long enough to know what "*****" MEANS......

Dont act like you simply stated, "rookie"

[_I Am_]

***** Rookie of the Year.

Awesome post...

And Horus, your a homie, but you are acting like a female in his thread...

[Rickety Cricket]

Lol at this whole thread. Horus you are such a whinny little bitch hypocrite, trying to tell other people to stop trolling Like everyone keeps a record of all their scorecards locked away in a fire proof safe, just for times like this to try and nut hug a fighter they have no connections with . Go ahead and put every on this site on ignore now.

[Horus]

R1: Mayweather

Floyds jab is keeping Castillo off balance, Floyd was mixing it up from the head to the body, and kept Castillo of balance...@ the 1:17 marker, Castillo misses a hard uppercut, showing the difference in speed and reaction time IMO... Castillo was basically annoyed...He didnt land anything of any value...Listening to FLOYDS CORNER AFTER THIS ROUND, YOU CAN SEE CASTILLO IS ALREADY BLEEDING FROM ACCURATE SHARP PUNCHING.....ACCORDING TO COMPUBOX HE (CASTILLO) THREW x27 PUNCHES AND LANDED ONLY X3!!!

R2: Mayweather

Rinse and repeat of round 1

R3: Mayweather

Mayweather rules the ring with that consistently landed jab to the body....I think this is where Castillo realizes he's got to be a little more agressive to land on floyd and pressure him, in the center of the ring, he cant land anything...Towards the end of round 3, he sees a glimmer of hope in trying to trap mayweather in the corners....

R4: Mayweather

While I agree with you Horus in this being mayweathers round, I can see how people scoring this could possibly give it to Castillo, this was a more active round, for castillo. I think this is why people literally try and give this round to Castillo, because he looks better than the 3 previous rounds...@the 1:06 marker you can see floyd grimmacing in pain as Castillo is hitting while the ref is saying stop.... hes desperate...He definitely wants to slow this fight down as he realizes attacking mayweather on the breaks is easier than in the center of the ring..lol

R5: Mayweather

From 2:34 - 2:15 I see an effective matador in Mayweather.. Castillo is consistently missing.
Ripping short left hook @ 2:10, but Castillo takes it like a champ though (THAT EXTRA WEIGHT MOST DEFINITELY IS HELPING HIM HERE)...this round is definitely mayweathers..But harold lederman gives the round to Castillo, because of his power shots, 15 out of 30... mayweather 7 out of 13, but mayweathers jabs are doing their job... but castillo didnt win this round at all. I think here I notice people listening to the HBO staff and getting the impression that the fight is close as Lampley states the fight is getting close at the beginning of round six, which it has been total domination for floyd so far...Might be better to watch this fight with the sound off....

R6: Castillo

is coming on with good pressure, but I think he realizes this is the only way to get into this fight, but it must be known that mayweather has just won the last 15 minutes prior, so he had to slow down a bit. He took some punishment, and Castillo was definitely coming in round six. But this works both ways, there is no way castillo can keep that kind of pressure on forever. and that leads to the same soup reheated Round 7 in favor of FLOYD.....

R7: Mayweather

He dominates the majority of this round. countering, MOVING ETC. It seems his rest in round six has paid off, but Castillo is once again coming on strong towards the end of the round...Larry Merchant is a lot closer in his judging as he has it 4-2 around the 2:08 marker he gives his results thus far, and is having it ahead for mayweather, but once again I can only give Castillo what he has earned and thats round 6. I see no reason to give him anything else.

R8: Mayweather

Point loss for Castillo makes this a 10-8 round in favor of FLOYD. Castillo realizes what I already suspected Floyd is just too fast, and Castillo wants to rough house illegally the smaller man Floyd. The left hook at 2:30 marker shows Castillo is tired, hes waltzing in the center of the ring, and there is no way he can beat floyd there. @ the 57 marker its super apparent how tored Castillo is, Floyd actually runs past him, and ends up behind castillo. What I have noticed is this, as long as CASTILLO'S FEET ARE ANYWHERE NEAR THAT CENTER BUDWEISER LOGO, HES getting whooped on, just an observation of mine and my opinion. I dont see how lederman scored it a 9-9 round, and castillo had a point deduction.

R9: CASTILLO

Coming on with good pressure, but he's only doinmg it in spurts, he does it, and then takes the next round off. Most people dont notice the weight advantage here, and to be honest its not even apparent as castillo hasnt even hurt mayweather, even though hes over teh welterweight limit in this fight, which is not a welter weight fight.This is definitely his round though.

R10: Mayweather

Big George called it, Mayweather meets him on the budweiser logo (THE CENTER OF THE RING) @ MAYWEATHER IS HAVING HIS WAY AT THE 1:11 MARKER I SEE A NICE CRISP SHOT FROM FLOYD, FLOYD IS MAKING HIM MISS. THE POINT DEDUCTION HELPS CASTILLO WHO REALLY LANDS HARDLY ANYTHING. NOW I AGREE THAT THE POINT REDUCTION WAS UNDERSTANDABLE, BUT CASTILLO WAS LITERALLY HITTING FLOYD IN THE BACK....
R11: Castillo

CASTILLO IS PRESSURING, HARD WORK AT THIS POINT PAYING OFF.

R12: Castillo

I HAVE TO GIVE CASTILLO THE LAST ROUND AS WELL.

ROUNDS 6,9,11,12 ARE THE ROUNDS CASTILLO WON... HARDLY ENOUGH TO WIN THIS BOUT.

I HAVE BEEN BEHIND THE SCENES WATCHING THE REPLYS AND COMMENTS FOR QUITE SOMETIME.

HERES WHAT I SAW, I SAW A BIGGER CASTILLO WIN X4 ROUNDS, I SAW A BIGGER HEAVIER CASTILLO LOSE x8 ROUNDS.

8+4= 12

Floyd has clearly won 8 rounds, even if you take an additional round from Floyd, its still a 7-5 fight for FLOYD MAYWEATHER.

People say this is the blue print to beat floyd, what I say to that is this...
This is the blue print to beat anyone except FLOYD, come in heavier, hit on the breaks etc.It wasnt just pressure in this fight floyd is fighting a damn welterweight and remember he moved up TO 135!!!! people give floyd so much flack but forget that floyd moved up basically 2 divisions to fight castillo, looking at castillos weight. But they crucify floyd for this versus marquez, even though floyd only came in 2 pounds heavier. Floyd went up to fight at 135, and ended up fighting a welterweight, and people say look!!! thats the strategy!!! NOT REALIZING THEY ARE SAYING!!! LOOK THE STRATEGY IS TO BE 9 POUNDS HEAVIER, HIT ON BREAKS ETC. ALL AT A DIVISION TEH MAN HAS NEVER EVEN FOUGHT AT PRIOR. This is why this type of strategy has never been replicated, because from taht moment on, mayweather didnt allow himself to be so handicapped against, until we get to another champion in delahoya, who lost just as well, coming in heavier, and punching wildly when they tied up...This is what makes MAYWEATHER SO SPECIAL TO TRAINED EYES.

YOU MOVE UP, TO FIGHT AT 135 AND OUTBOX A 147 PONDER???
THAT TAKES SKILL! This is why we never see PAC DOING THIS, ITS CATCHWEIGHT CITY FOR HIM...
Castillo weighed 147 and Mayweather weighed 138

THIS IS A FACT.


A fight will not even go down like this anymore.

MANNY WILL NOT PRESSURE FLOYD LIKE THIS.

MANNY WILL NOT BE BIGGER, NOR HEAVIER, MANY WILL NOT OUTWEIGH FLOYD BY OVER 9 POUNDS... HES IS NOT TALLER, NOR IS HE GOING TO HAVE ONLY 2" SHORTER ARMS, FLOYD IS AROUND 72" AND CASTILLO 70".

PEOPLE BETTER WAKE UP.

Great Post and Great Analysis.
Not just because u pick Mayweather to win. But because you broke down each round, and explain why you felt Mayweather or Castillo won or lost the rounds u score for them. My intention with this thread was to get people to actually analyzed and breakdown the fight instead of generalizing the whole fight base on 4 rounds. And I agree with you on the 9 pounds. Jose Luis Castillo in a lightweight championship fight came in on fight night 14 pounds over the lightweight limit and weighing "9 Pounds" heavier the Floyd Mayweather who weigh 140 on that night. That decision by Castillo Single Handley created a Theory, Gameplan, and Strategy to somehow beat Mayweather which to this day is still in effect.

However To this day Majority People Believe those 9 pounds were MAJORITY OF THE reason Castillo gave Mayweather Problems... and Those 9 pounds People Still believe are what is needed in order to give Mayweather problems. In any future fight he is in.

Thats why want to see Mayweather fight bigger fighters. But in this fight Castillo in majority of the rounds took to long to get started and Mayweather as you said dominated in the middle of the ring. it was truly a great fight to watch because it was a perfect clash of styles displayed that night.

GREAT POST and analysis my dude.