Alexander Drops Below Maidana In Ring Ratings

[Bastian Loc]

Yeah i reckon so.

Most everyone did.

The Alexander bubble should've realistically burst when Urango started figuring him out and if it didn't by then Kotelnik totally shattered it.

The Bradley fight wasn't even close imo and if anyone still thinks Alexander is anything but another hbo hypejob after all this they're a pathetic excuse for a boxing analyst.

You alright? Your not known for giving in easily

I wanna make up with you and start fresh. I've always thought we could be better friends.

[Prince Boateng]

Its J.Lo man. He doesn't care about facts.

He only cares about his opinions and everyone else be damned. That wouldn't be so bad if he didn't pretend to be objective or knowledgeable.




Fine.



Maidana beat Kotelnik so that's impossible.

O yes...just like Paul Williams is better than Margarito (PRIME Margarito) cus Paul lit him up........

[cleaner147]

Man what the hell did the Ring do their ratings? They have a champion in every division now.

what do you mean. the most titles are vacant.

[jrosales13]

Yeah i reckon so.

Well that is all I needed to know.

[jrosales13]

no, youre lookin at it the wrong way man. you cant look for that single win and say that win is better than what he did the last 2 years.

No you look as a resume in the division as a whole. Agree that also what you have done for me lately. And, Kotelnik arguably beat a top 5 fighter in his last fight while Maidana lost.

one shtty performances against chop chop is no apocalypse since he proved against Khan what hes made of.

I can use that same argument that one shutout lost to Khan is no apocalypse since he proved against a prime Witter, Miadana, and Alexander.

I always support Kotelnik, but I have a feelin you hate Maidana. Maidana cant be compared with Urgano.

I have a feeling that you do not understand the argument. Who compared Maidana to Urango? The comparison was Urango to Ortiz. Please pay attention.

Im trying to use your arguments look now:

Maidanas shttyy win against chop chop>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Kotelniks one-sided defeat to Khan

Why pick and choose the fight though? I mean if we can pick and choose the fight. Then I will pick....

Kotelnik performance against Alexander>>>>>>>Maidana performance against Corley.

[cleaner147]

No you look as a resume in the division as a whole. Agree that also what you have done for me lately. And, Kotelnik arguably beat a top 5 fighter in his last fight while Maidana lost.

-whos dat top 5? overrated Alexander? he officially never beat him.

I can use that same argument that one shutout lost to Khan is no apocalypse since he proved against a prime Witter, Miadana, and Alexander.

-he has lost both fights and got a hometown gift against Maidana.

I have a feeling that you do not understand the argument. Who compared Maidana to Urango? The comparison was Urango to Ortiz. Please pay attention.

-

Why pick and choose the fight though? I mean if we can pick and choose the fight. Then I will pick....

Kotelnik performance against Alexander>>>>>>>Maidana performance against Corley.

-which one was the more important fight........a tune up or Kotelnik's biggest fight

bolded......................

[jrosales13]

-which one was the more important fight........a tune up or Kotelnik's biggest fight

Well if we're talking about not officially winning, like we should then lets not mention Maidana fights against Kotelnik and Khan since he didn't officially beat them.

And, yes Alexander was a top fight guy at the time. Matter of fact Kotelnik has an official win over a current top 5 in Maidana. Maidana has zero official wins over any top 5 guy.

He got a hometown give against Maidana just like Maidana got a hometown gift against Corley. Which one is worse?

[cleaner147]

Well if we're talking about not officially winning, like we should then lets not mention Maidana fights against Kotelnik and Khan since he didn't officially beat them.

And, yes Alexander was a top fight guy at the time. Matter of fact Kotelnik has an official win over a current top 5 in Maidana. Maidana has zero official wins over any top 5 guy.

He got a hometown give against Maidana just like Maidana got a hometown gift against Corley. Which one is worse?

seriously, did Corley win that fight?

I have no problem that Kotelnik beat Maidana, but in that time where the fight happened, Maidana wasnt ranked in the top 5...
Maidana got up in American rankings when he beat Ortiz and Cayo.

Maidana improved and overtook Kotelnik at least with the Khan fight. thats my opinion. I love the 140 division cuz its loaded with young talented fighters with different styles and personalties. all are still green (aside Kotelnik) and have their faults. that makes it very interesing. peace

[jrosales13]

seriously, did Corley win that fight?

Corley won that fight just as much as Maidana won the Kotelnik and Khan fights.

I have no problem that Kotelnik beat Maidana, but in that time where the fight happened, Maidana wasnt ranked in the top 5...
Maidana got up in American rankings when he beat Ortiz and Cayo.

True, but he's top 5 now, there are no wins in Maidana resume of any fighter that was rank top 5 at the time or now.

Maidana improved and overtook Kotelnik at least with the Khan fight. thats my opinion.

Well he hasn't improve that much cuz' if he did he wouldn't have trouble with that version of Corley. I mean Jose Alfaro KO'd Corley FFS's.

I love the 140 division cuz its loaded with young talented fighters with different styles and personalties. all are still green (aside Kotelnik) and have their faults. that makes it very interesing. peace

140 is overrated IMO. Is not that deep. It really is just Bradley and Khan and the rest are eh..........

[cleaner147]

...HAHA you ***

Maidana put a great effort, for some a winning one, against Kotelnik and a FOTY against Khan who got almost KTFO and pwnd on the inside.
Corley's best punch was a head butt which cut Maidana. no comparison at all.

Im not saying 140 is p4p the best division. It never was.
But its the deepest one with young talented up and comers in the moment.
a very young division which fighters have different styles, different personalities, huge talents. the best about it is they are fightin eachother. best is fightin the best in that division.

1.Bradley (the man to beat)
2.Khan (star and cash cow)
the next are close
3.Maidana (FOTY-boxer)
4.Kotelnik
5.Alexander

and I think that ranking could change very soon. thats what makes it interesting.

**** off now