What's your new 140 lb ranking! Top 10!

[jrosales13]

You dont have Matthyse in the top 10?

It was between him and Judah and technically won.

Peterson has technically a draw against Ortiz. That is better than a dominating win over a shot to shit Corley.

I mean Matthyse best wins are against shot to **** fighters like Corley and Harris. If you look at his resume that are his 2 best wins...

I mean he fought competitive against Judah(who is very past prime and about to be a shot fighter soon) and technically lost. So I can't put him ahead of Judah.

[MXboxingfan]

It was between him and Judah and technically won.

Peterson has technically a draw against Ortiz. That is better than a dominating win over a shot to shit Corley.

I mean Matthyse best wins are against shot to **** fighters like Corley and Harris. If you look at his resume that are his 2 best wins...

I mean he fought competitive against Judah(who is very past prime and about to be a shot fighter soon) and technically lost. So I can't put him ahead of Judah.

Mathysse is more deserving of the top ten than Victor Ortiz.

[jrosales13]

Mathysse is more deserving of the top ten than Victor Ortiz.

Not really, both have wins against shot fighter in Harris. Both were early KO's.

A draw against a PRIME Peterson>a Matthysse best win of his career against a shot Corley.

And, his dominating wins over past prime-shot fighters in Diaz and Campbell>a competitive lost/win(depending how you had it, it was close either way) against a past prime-shot Judah.

And, I'm not even an Ortiz fight. I might be a bigger fan of Matthysse than Ortiz. But, he's resume is still very very weak. He might beat Ortiz H2H...Matter of fact I would put money on Mattheysse to beat Ortiz. But, I don't rank guys on H2H I rank by resume.

[boxer2k5]

Bradley easy number 1 unified champion plus the longest champion even fought a tough dude at welter. undefeated best resume in the division. anyone who dont have timmy at num 1 should quit watching boxing.

Devon who was number 2 moves to 3 while Khan moves to number 2 as he is a belt holder.
Khan vs Bradley needs to happen so we can have an undisputed champion. thats the next best fight to be made.

4 Maidana
5 Koltielnik
6 Mbuoza(winner of judah fight moves to 3rd.)
7 Ortiz(about to fight at welter)
8 Judah(winner moves to 3rd)
9 Mythesse
10 Peterson

Sorry for misspelling pretty much everyone name wrong.

[Bastian Loc]

1. Amir Khan
2. Juan Manuel Marquez (as soon as he makes the jump which will happen soon)
3A. Marcos Maidana
3B. Tim Bradley
5. Zab Judah
6. Andriy Kotelnik
7. Lucas Matthysse
8. Victor Ortiz
9. Lamont Peterson
10. Devon Alexander

This looks about right.^^

I'd go:

1)Khan
2)Maidana
3)Mathysse
4)Kotelnik
5)Bradley
6)Peterson
7)Ortiz
8)Mabuza
9)Judah
10)Alexander

[Bastian Loc]

1. Bradley
2. Khan
3. Kotelnik
4. Maidana
5. Alexander
6. Ortiz
7. Peterson
8. Mabuza
9. Matthysse
10. Judah

My rankings, using my own scorings (in fights such as Kotelnik-Alexander and Matthysse-Judah) rather than the official judging.

I use the same approach. Which is why I rank Maidana above Kotelnik. Had him winning that fight.

[Faerun]

1. Bradley
2. Khan
3. Kotelnik
4. Maidana
5. Alexander
6. Ortiz
7. Peterson
8. Mabuza
9. Matthysse
10. Judah

My rankings, using my own scorings (in fights such as Kotelnik-Alexander and Matthysse-Judah) rather than the official judging.

Reasonable rankings. It's beyond me how some users have Kotelnik behind Maidana and Alexander when he beat both of them!? Dude's no flashy American but what he does, he does right.

[ny123]

1-Bradley
2-Khan
3-Kotelnik
4-Alexander
5-Maidana
6-Matthyse
7-Ortiz
8-Peterson
9-Urango
10-Judah

I never saw Mabuza fight and missed Kotelnik-Maidana so that affects my rankings.

[DonairesRevenge]

#1. Khan
#2. Maidana
#3. Bradley
#4. Kotelnik
#5. Alexander
#6. Matthysse
#7. Judah
#8. Ortiz
#9. Mckloskey
#10.Holt

[Pugilistic™]

1. Timothy Bradley
2. Amir Khan
3. Andriy Kotelnik
4. Devon Alexander
5. Marcos Maidana
6. Victor Ortiz
7. Lamont Peterson
8. Kaizer Mabuza
9. Zab Judah
10. Lucas Matthysse