My SMW Rankings; Carl Froch is The #1 SMW

[The_Demon]

You cant honestly rank Bute above Ward,simple as that

[ИATAS]

and thats perfectly understandable, I rank Bute ahead because of the way he dominated better the fighter they have in common.

that is ******ed because Ward dominated Kessler.

They've fought what, two guys in common? Bika & Miranda?

Ward dominated Miranda and Bute knocked Miranda the F out. They fight differently and obviously bute has more power then Ward.

[Check]

Ward is the number 1 guy. Whats really bad is you having Lucian Bute at number 2 though.

[studentofthegam]

Super MiddleWeight
Champion: Vacant

1.Carl Froch 27-1-0(20KOs) WBC
2.Lucian Bute 27-0-0(22KOs) IBF
3.Andre Ward 23-0-0(13KOs) WBA
4.Mikkel Kessler 43-2-0(32KOs)
5.Andre Dirrell 19-1-0(13KOs)
6.Glen Johnson 51-14-2(35KOs)
7.Arthur Abraham 31-2-0(25KOs)
8.Librado Andrade 29-3-0(22KOs)
9.Robert Stieglitz 38-2-0(23KOs) WBO
10.Dimitry Sartison 27-1-(17KOs)

Carl Froch is the rightfull #1 SMW

Ward is easily the class of the division. He beat Kessler handily. Froch got a gift against ***in Dirrel. Froch is a tough little a**hole but not that great of a boxer. Bute hasnt even fought a top five opponent.

[Toney Loc]

I love Bute but he doesn't have a better resume than Ward. Sure it's close but Ward has Kessler and Green. Bute has Andrade and Miranda (who Ward had already beaten). I'd pick Ward. I fully agree about Froch, though.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

First of all resume wise none of the SMW gets even close to Froch.

Second Ward and Bute are close in the resume department, you may have Ward above Bute because of the Kessler win, I have Bute over because they are prety even with the exeption that the opponents they have in common Bute have KO them or beat more convincingly.

Laughable logic

[武士道]

Lethargy Ward beats them all.

[*OG Wenger*]

ward or bute dont get ranked above a guy who has wins over pascal, taylor, dirrell and abraham on his record in my opinion....

[ChampBox@PR]

that is ******ed because Ward dominated Kessler.

They've fought what, two guys in common? Bika & Miranda?

Ward dominated Miranda and Bute knocked Miranda the F out. They fight differently and obviously bute has more power then Ward.

Ward headuttted the living **** out of Kesler dude. In any other place he would had gotten taken 2 points away, atleast. But Wards poosie ass refuses to leave Oakland.

Ward is the number 1 guy. Whats really bad is you having Lucian Bute at number 2 though.

How is Ward the #1 guy?

[ChampBox@PR]

ward or bute dont get ranked above a guy who has wins over pascal, taylor, dirrell and abraham on his record in my opinion....

Thank You!!!!