Who is the biggest Cherry Picker between Manny and Floyd?

[Tomislav III]

Lets see, floyd earned his titles at legit weights and against actual contenders in that division

manny pacquiao has thus far:

Erik Morales
Juan Manuel Marquez
Marco Antonio Barrera
Ricky Hatton
Joshua Clottey
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito



And numerous B level fighters that contend admirably against almost any other fighter.


Enough with this bull**** about resumes. First, you don't know **** about fighting if you think that any fight is a given.


Second, if you think that his resume is so full of bums, then you fight them. They're bums right? You have an even chance with them. Bum vs. a bum. If it's so easy to get a title, you'll have no problem.


Third, in this era of boxing, every resume is going to be objectionable. There isn't a name out here that I couldnt accuse of ducking.


It even gets old when people accuse Mayweather of it. If you know boxing, you can point out the flaws in a fighter's style, not the flaws in his opponents.


But, as Roger Mayweather would say, you don't know **** about boxing.

[SplitSecond]

manny pacquiao never ducked anyone

floyd mayweather on the other hand.....

[Phenom]

Roach is legendary for his match making the easiest styles and matching Manny with the weakest belt holder at a division for a one and done. Manny took it to a whole new level with catchweights and vacant belt

dude even cherry picked a fighter who did not have a boxing license to fight him for a vacant belt at a catchweight thats legendary cherry picking right there. when has Floyd stooped that low?

[Bushbaby]

Roach is legendary for his match making the easiest styles and matching Manny with the weakest belt holder at a division for a one and done. Manny took it to a whole new level with catchweights and vacant belt

dude even cherry picked a fighter who did not have a boxing license to fight him for a vacant belt at a catchweight thats legendary cherry picking right there. when has Floyd stooped that low?

This here,this right here****,is exactly why I renounced my fanhood of Pacman,well said!!

[pbftxrs316]

damn, last time i checked, floyd has fought the 2 undisputed ww champions and have dominated them and they were both coming off of wins---floyd also fought the undisputed ww champion in zab judah--he has never fought for a champion at catchweights and manny has fought the same guys floyd is getting criticized for fighting all of a sudden--

the obvious answer is manny

in 2010 alone, he fought 2 losers---the last time clottey and margarito fought big fights against top notch opponents, they lost---

the last 5 times floyd has fought, his opponents were all coming off of big wins by tko and ko--simple as that

manny is a cherry picker, not floyd--who has floyd not fought?

margarito and cotto--if you all don't know the story around that by now, then you all will never know--you're lames anyway--lol

[IMDAZED]

Floyd was pretty ****ty in 2006 but Margarito and Mosley back to back takes the cake. Then again, it's all about whether or not you can do it. If the fans let you get away with it, why wouldn't you? Mayweather got to the point where he couldn't do it anymore because the media was raping him at every turn. Pacquiao seems above that and thus, will continue doing it.

[Alibata]

I'm surprised 53 people voted for Manny.. The answer is so obvious that in the real world this poll would be a blow out.

[IMDAZED]

I'm surprised 53 people voted for Manny.. The answer is so obvious that in the real world this poll would be a blow out.

LOL @ Alibitter talking about the real world with a fake quote in his sig.

[Dynamite Kid]

Let put it like this.........

Oscar was heavily favoured to KO Manny.

There were number of people who thought Hatton would be too big for him, IE, Manny Steward being of the more high profile.

Malignaggi and plenty of others that Cotto would be too much for him, cant recall too many thinking Marquez had a legitimate chances.

[IMDAZED]

Let put it like this.........

Oscar was heavily favoured to KO Manny.

There were number of people who thought Hatton would be too big for him, IE, Manny Steward being of the more high profile.

Malignaggi and plenty of others that Cotto would be too much for him, cant recall too many thinking Marquez had a legitimate chances.

Agreed, DK. Manny had a spectacular run from 08-09. But what's transpired since...disgusting.