Is Vitali Klitschko a top 10 heavyweight of all time?

[Mersey]

Not top 10. Plus, Wlad should be ranked higher than him.

[DET. IRONSIDE]

Not top 10. Plus, Wlad should be ranked higher than him.

So you take resume over skills and entertainment value?

I agree.

[Mersey]

So you take resume over skills and entertainment value?

I agree.

If skills and entertainment value was the most important thing, Tyson would be the GOAT.

But it doesn't work like that.

[Rabbit ♠]

I have him right behind Wlad and Spider Rico.

[DiegoFuego]

is this a joke? Top 30 maybe

[Money Shot]

His resume is ****, it's even worse than Wlad's.

Tyson, Holyfield, Lewis, Bowe all had ALOT better resumes than Vitali and none of them is in the top 5.

Vitali doesn't have ONE single great win in his ENTIRE career, his resume is made on fat slobs like peter and arreola, mediocre fighters like danny ****in williams and kevin johnson, has beens like shannon briggs... Hell Lennox Lewis stopped a prime Briggs in 5 rounds while Vitali couldn't even stop a 39 year old shot briggs.

Bowe? Did I read that correctly!? Bowe!? LOL Keep taking the tablets. Yeah, Bowe the guy who was retired by Andrew Golota has a better resume than Vitali. It's not Vitali's fault he's knocked out 9 out every ten opponents. He'd do the same to your lard assed Ridiculous Bowe, any version. As far as Holyfield, yeah I doubt Bert Cooper would have had Vitali out on his feet. I'd take Vitali to knock out Louis, Marciano, Dempsey, Frazier, and Johnson and Tyson, whatever their 'resume' says.

[NChristo]

Resume is everything when ranking ATGs, Vitali is not a top 10 ATG because his resume kind of sucks, also he lost to the 2 best boxers he ever faced I really don't see how people can view him as this unbeatable machine to be honest.

[DiegoFuego]

Bowe? Did I read that correctly!? Bowe!? LOL Keep taking the tablets. Yeah, Bowe the guy who was retired by Andrew Golota has a better resume than Vitali. It's not Vitali's fault he's knocked out 9 out every ten opponents. He'd do the same to your lard assed Ridiculous Bowe, any version. As far as Holyfield, yeah I doubt Bert Cooper would have had Vitali out on his feet. I'd take Vitali to knock out Louis, Marciano, Dempsey, Frazier, and Johnson and Tyson, whatever their 'resume' says.

And I highly doubt Chris Byrd would knock out Holyfield or Bowe.

To not factor in resume, you are only ranking on potential.

Resume is not for the "could have" but the "actually did" fighters. Holyfield and Bowe are far ahead of Vitali.

[SOPH~ REP.]

hell to the no

[DET. IRONSIDE]

Bowe? Did I read that correctly!? Bowe!? LOL Keep taking the tablets. Yeah, Bowe the guy who was retired by Andrew Golota has a better resume than Vitali. It's not Vitali's fault he's knocked out 9 out every ten opponents. He'd do the same to your lard assed Ridiculous Bowe, any version. As far as Holyfield, yeah I doubt Bert Cooper would have had Vitali out on his feet. I'd take Vitali to knock out Louis, Marciano, Dempsey, Frazier, and Johnson and Tyson, whatever their 'resume' says.

Guys who could UD Vitali:

Max Baer, Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore, Floyd Patterson, Jersey Joe Walcott< Michael Spinks, Jack Sharkey