How incredible would Pac Vs Shane have been in his prime?

[DARKSEID]

They're both guys who probably nobody else can beat in a slugfest, or an all out brawl(in their primes).. and no doubt, it was definitely gonna be an all out brawl. They're both guys who never let you get the last hit, and who only come back harder the harder it gets.

it would have been interesting to see who the better fighter would have been, in that type of fight(the most exciting kind)

Personally I think Shane would have knocked Pac out. He was too fast, too powerful and too big.

[Tomislav III]

What was Shane Mosley's prime? Beating Philip Holliday?


Or by prime do you mean, period of EPO and steroid abuse?



The former, no.

The latter.... Well, EPO does wonders really.

[check hook]

They're both guys who probably nobody else can beat in a slugfest, or an all out brawl(in their primes).. and no doubt, it was definitely gonna be an all out brawl. They're both guys who never let you get the last hit, and who only come back harder the harder it gets.

it would have been interesting to see who the better fighter would have been, in that type of fight(the most exciting kind)

Personally I think Shane would have knocked Pac out. He was too fast, too powerful and too big.

The Shane that fought Oscar in fight number one would spark MP out, as would that version of Oscar and Tito around that time. These guys were big strong welters who were fast and hit hard. They would destroy the majority of WW today. Look at what Shane did to Margarito as a 38 year old. If the Shane that fought Oscar fought Margarito he would have cracked his skull open like a coconut.

[Rassclot]

Pac beats any version of Oscar. too fast and Oscar is tailor made. Pac will keep turning him.



Mosley is tougher but mosley roided out his grills. so can't say. 50/50.

[DARKSEID]

What was Shane Mosley's prime? Beating Philip Holliday?


Or by prime do you mean, period of EPO and steroid abuse?



The former, no.

The latter.... Well, EPO does wonders really.

The period of epo and steroid abuse.

[frankenfrank]

They're both guys who probably nobody else can beat in a slugfest, or an all out brawl(in their primes).. and no doubt, it was definitely gonna be an all out brawl. They're both guys who never let you get the last hit, and who only come back harder the harder it gets.

it would have been interesting to see who the better fighter would have been, in that type of fight(the most exciting kind)

Personally I think Shane would have knocked Pac out. He was too fast, too powerful and too big.

Which is why it never occurred .
But during Shane's prime Pacquiao was far below him in weight .
Still Freddie kept Pacquiao away from Mosley even years after Mosley's prime was over , but now he believes that Shane is done enough .

[LoStranger]

Prime Mosley beats Manny all day IMO

[Bushbaby]

Pac beats any version of Oscar. too fast and Oscar is tailor made. Pac will keep turning him.



Mosley is tougher but mosley roided out his grills. so can't say. 50/50.

U have never seen the Oscar that fought Tito or Mosley in the 1st fight & if U did & still say this,Ur ******,plain & simple!!

[Malius]

I think this is a troll post cos the title should really be.

How would prime(steroid) mosley go against Prime Mayweather/Pacman?

Although Shane was coming of a Marg win he wasn't in his prime.

Personally I think if Shane went to the body all night against either Floyd/Manny he has a damn good chance. But both should beat him comfortably.