Outside of Manny and Floyd,

[Buffalo]

140 would be my opinion as well

[Vasyl’s dad]

i think PAC just should just beat up the junior welter division...including Khan

If that were to happen,

"Pac won a belt at 154 and now hes picking on smaller guys".


Guarantee it.

[Tomislav III]

Andre Berto and then the list dwindles to guys that don't even make gatekeeper.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Andre Berto and then the list dwindles to guys that don't even make gatekeeper.

What makes Berto the best? He hasn't fought anyone significant.

[horge]

If that were to happen,

"Pac won a belt at 154 and now hes picking on smaller guys".


Guarantee it.

Which is why I was pimping the Martinez fight so hard.
Once you go up in weight, there's no fully coming back.
You'll be under criticism for picking on little guys if you do.

If I had it my way, Pac would have kept busy with either
Marquez (freakshow, but JMM's fanbase wants a trilogy,
and on cinco de Mayo weekend?), or Berto (who can argue
against legit defense/move towards unifying WW?); then,
assuming Floyd's still too busy, fight Martinez with both
the JMW and MW straps on the line and retire.

[Tomislav III]

What makes Berto the best? He hasn't fought anyone significant.

He hasn't, but at the same time... He hasn't lost and he does have a belt. I'm not saying he's head and shoulders above everyone else, but whereas with everyone else you can pick out significant flaws in their performances, you can't really do that too badly with Berto, so it gives him some edge if only for the mystery.

Again, not a great fighter, but we haven't seen enough to determin H2H.

[sicko]

lol people can't even answer this question because THEY DON'T KNOW ANYBODY AT WELTERWEIGHT besides Mayweather and Pacquiao lol

but after Pacquiao and Mayweather is:

3. Andre Berto
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Kell Brook
6. Jan Zaveck
7. Alfonso Gomez
8. Viacheslav Senchenko
9. Mike Jones
10. Selcuk Aydin

but it is so many fighters at 154 who can fight at 147 as well, but of course that division is going to become weak when the Top 2 Fighters in the division don't want to fight the rest of the contenders in the divison

that is why the 140 division and the 168 division is the BEST divisions in boxing...because they are all fighting each other!

[Equinox]

Good thread
Pacquiao vs Zaveck November 2011.

[Vasyl’s dad]

With so many people slamming Shane lately, I thought we'd have at least 15 pages of posts naming 5 welterweights better than Mosley.

What happened?

[Prime 407]

With so many people slamming Shane lately, I thought we'd have at least 15 pages of posts naming 5 welterweights better than Mosley.

What happened?

Good thread, exposed a lot of illogical ***** logic