Who would win Winky or Taylor?

[Martin (Top Knowledge)]

I would have to say Winky by UD... Taylor would have some success, but he'd get out-boxed.

And the guy who started this thread... Winky's not clearly Middleweight, infact he's spent his whole career fighting at Light-middleweight. 6lbs makes A LOT of difference in this game!

[PerfectPunch]

Pfffft, now I hope that is sarcasm.

Winky would with by a UD. It wouldn't be close. Somewhere around the lines of 9-3 or 8-4. Winky's defense is too good and Taylor is too green to find a way to penetrate it.

no i wasnt being sarcastic i was just proving the other guys point that hopkins did get slightly stunned in r.2.

like i said earlier winky would put on a boxing masterclass and taylor wouldnt be able to connect as well against wrights great defence. wright would use his good jab to outpoint taylor for a relatively easy UD.

[Dirt E Gomez]

no i wasnt being sarcastic i was just proving the other guys point that hopkins did get slightly stunned in r.2.

Nah, if you have the fight on you computer watch it, and while it looks and sounds like it connects it doesn't. At the end of the round when they show the shot from another angle it hits Hopkins square between the shoulder blades on the back and it slides up grazing his head slightly. He wasn't stunned, simply knocked off balance.

But you're right about Winky.

[The Troll]

McClellan KO 1 Wright
McClellan KO 1 Taylor

Winky UD....Taylor

[PerfectPunch]

Nah, if you have the fight on you computer watch it, and while it looks and sounds like it connects it doesn't. At the end of the round when they show the shot from another angle it hits Hopkins square between the shoulder blades on the back and it slides up grazing his head slightly. He wasn't stunned, simply knocked off balance.

But you're right about Winky.

i havent unfortunatley but ill dl it and have a closer look

[AintGottaClue]

Felix Sturm would win of course, o **** wait thats not the topic doh my bad

[InThisCorner]

Sturm couldn't even beat Oscar...










Even though he should of......










It was still reasonably close, and Oscar wasn't a true middleweight by any means.

[AintGottaClue]

Sturm couldn't even beat Oscar...










Even though he should of......










It was still reasonably close, and Oscar wasn't a true middleweight by any means.

u mean sturm wining 8-10 rounds in the fight is close?

[Parodius]

McClellan KO 1 Wright
McClellan KO 1 Taylor

Winky UD....Taylor

Boy MacKay you really overrating McClellan. I liked McClellan & I feel bad for him, but he couldn't even beat Benn. Taylor beats Benn, McClellan & Mr. Boring Winky any day. I don't see any of these ever beating Taylor.

[chito]

Taylor by split decision!