Khan has the best resume at 140

[Drunk Punch]

Not necessarily. I'd argue that if Bradley beats Alexander he draws level with Khan.

Then they fight it out for the no1 spot.

[bruzza]

Khan also fought a Prime Barrera.

/jk

Hahahaha. I mean you just got to laugh

[talz]

The rankings don't matter so much at the moment because when its all said and done the winner of bradley/alex will fight khan, to determine the #1 at 140.

[Grimmer]

Khan also fought a Prime Barrera.

Khan also fought a prime, undefeated Breidis Prescott.

[£-4-£]

1. Khan (Maidana, Kotelnik, Malignaggi, Salita)
2. Bradley (Holt, Peterson, Witter)
3. Alexander (Kotelnik, Witter, Urango)

Malignaggi is a better name to have on your resume than Peterson or Holt:

Malignaggi:

- Former world-champion with 2 successful defense.
- Had a close fight with Cotto.
- Challenged Hatton for the lineal title at 140lbs.
- Notable wins over N'dou (x2), N'goudjo, and 2 wins over Juan Diaz.

Peterson:

- Former WBO-champion (0 defenses).
- No marquee wins on his resume.

Holt:

- Former WBO champion.
- Notable wins over Ricardo Torres, Demetrius Hopkins, David Diaz.
- Loses against Torres, Thomas Davis? wtf.
- Gone on to lose vs. Mabuza.

Therefore, Khan's win over Malignaggi (in Malignaggi's home-town) is better than Bradley's wins over Peterson and Holt.

Bradley's win over Witter is impressive, and was in the UK. But Witter was past-prime, but his win is better than Alexander's win over Witter.

Khan beat a prime-Kotelnik, dominated him infact for 12 rounds. Alexander LOST to Kotelnik, 8 rounds to 4 IMO. So Khan's resume is automatically better than Alexander's.

Khan's win over a prime-Maidana, who was in the shape of his life, is better than Bradley's wins over Witter and Miguel Vazquez. Bradley's win over Edner Cherry is unremarkable, Cherry had 5 losses prior to fighting Bradley, Bradley was supposed to beat Cherry. Khan at least gets some credit for KO'ing Salita. Salita and Cherry were both C-class fighters.

Maidana > Miguel Vazquez, past-prime Witter, and Edner Cherry.

Khan has great wins over Maidana and Kotelnik. And a good win over Malignaggi.

Bradley has good wins over Peterson, Holt, past-prime Witter, and Vazquez.

Khan's resume > Bradley's.

1) Khan
2) Bradley
3) Kotelnik
4) Alexander

[The_Demon]

As of right now he does ye,hard to argue against that,if bradley beats devon id give him the edge

[minasyan]

Don't care what anyone says there is no way Devon won his fight against Kotelnik

So if you think about it Kotelnik has a pretty good resume beating Devon and Maidana

[Pacquiao'd]

Don't care what anyone says there is no way Devon won his fight against Kotelnik

So if you think about it Kotelnik has a pretty good resume beating Devon and Maidana

agree. devon CLEARLY lost. anyone that says otherwise is blind

[talz]

Malignaggi is a better name to have on your resume than Peterson or Holt:

Malignaggi:

- Former world-champion with 2 successful defense.
- Had a close fight with Cotto.
- Challenged Hatton for the lineal title at 140lbs.
- Notable wins over N'dou (x2), N'goudjo, and 2 wins over Juan Diaz.

Peterson:

- Former WBO-champion (0 defenses).
- No marquee wins on his resume.

Holt:

- Former WBO champion.
- Notable wins over Ricardo Torres, Demetrius Hopkins, David Diaz.
- Loses against Torres, Thomas Davis? wtf.
- Gone on to lose vs. Mabuza.

Therefore, Khan's win over Malignaggi (in Malignaggi's home-town) is better than Bradley's wins over Peterson and Holt.

Bradley's win over Witter is impressive, and was in the UK. But Witter was past-prime, but his win is better than Alexander's win over Witter.

Khan beat a prime-Kotelnik, dominated him infact for 12 rounds. Alexander LOST to Kotelnik, 8 rounds to 4 IMO. So Khan's resume is automatically better than Alexander's.

Khan's win over a prime-Maidana, who was in the shape of his life, is better than Bradley's wins over Witter and Miguel Vazquez. Bradley's win over Edner Cherry is unremarkable, Cherry had 5 losses prior to fighting Bradley, Bradley was supposed to beat Cherry. Khan at least gets some credit for KO'ing Salita. Salita and Cherry were both C-class fighters.

Maidana > Miguel Vazquez, past-prime Witter, and Edner Cherry.

Khan has great wins over Maidana and Kotelnik. And a good win over Malignaggi.

Bradley has good wins over Peterson, Holt, past-prime Witter, and Vazquez.

Khan's resume > Bradley's.

1) Khan
2) Bradley
3) Kotelnik
4) Alexander

Can't really argue with that, nicely put.