Will Amir Khan go down as Britain's greatest fighter?

[Pin Galarga]

NO. At 140 He can't even beat the top 3 fighters.

[Kagami Taiga]

He's already greater than Hatton let's be honest. Maidana is a better win than any on Hatton's record.

no, no hes not. tszyu owns any win in khans resume.

[jrosales13]

NO. At 140 He can't even beat the top 3 fighters.

He is a top 3 fighter at 140 what are you talking about? I have him at #2 but even if you feel Alexander should get #2 Khan is easily #3.

And, I think he beats Alexander, Bradley is a different story though.

[Kagami Taiga]

Hamed is greater than both Hatton and Cotto.

Hamed made too much money too early on to really care about legacy. In his prime he was way better than the guys you mentioned above.

he may have had the skills, but i dont place him that much higher. he loses to barerra and then quits the sport...barerra is a great fighter. hamed is below him.

[S.G.]

He can maybe be top ten / fifteen. He still looks beatable to me, though. And I don't just mean by a KO, he can probably be outboxed over twelve rounds by a clever boxer who isn't too small.

[Left Hook Tua]

Cotto would smash Hatton and go through everyone in his resume apart from Floyd & Pac.

cotto would have been put to sleep by the kostya hatton beat.

[Zig Zag.]

no. because people will always remember that he got knocked out by bum in under a minute.


Calzaghe is the greatest british fighter ever, as he beat a prime RJJ

[J-H]

Yes.

Hamed got Ktfo by Barrera and Khan's chin is world class as he proved Saturday.

Calzaghe is one of the most overrated fighters (if slapping is considered fighting) of all time who's best wins are two shot to shit fighters and Jeff Lacy.

Hatton has the boxing IQ of a doorknob.

Froch's boxing IQ is lower than Hatton's.

Lewis is a Jamaican from Canada.

Jimmy Wilde and Bob Fitzsimmons were two flat footed british bums with padded records and wins over other bums.



Amir Khan wins by default.

[SirTomJones]

no. because people will always remember that he got knocked out by bum in under a minute.


Calzaghe is the greatest british fighter ever, as he beat a prime RJJ

Not only did he beat prime RJJ he beat a prime Hopkins who had a prime Cortez backing him up.

[J-H]

Yes.

Hamed got Ktfo by Barrera and Khan's chin is world class as he proved Saturday.

Calzaghe is one of the most overrated fighters (if slapping is considered fighting) of all time who's best wins are two shot to shit fighters and Jeff Lacy.

Hatton as the boxing IQ of a doorknob.

Froch's boxing IQ is lower than Hatton's.

Lewis is a Jamaican from Canada.

Jimmy Wilde and Bob Fitzsimmons were two flat footed british bums with padded records and wins over other bums.



Amir Khan wins by default.

You don't know shit about boxing.