December 2011 Pound 4 Pound list

[_original_]

take amir out? and replace him with marcos maidana? hahahaha


amir put on a boxing clinic. re watch that fight closely and u might learn a thing or two about BOXING

I thought Amir looked brilliant in the first 8 or 9 rounds, but the way he finished that fight did not scream p4p to me

but hey it's your list and you're entitled to it...mine isn't exactly flawless

[G Doggy Dog]

I thought Amir looked brilliant in the first 8 or 9 rounds, but the way he finished that fight did not scream p4p to me

but hey it's your list and you're entitled to it...mine isn't exactly flawless

marcos fought a tough fight and amir rose to the occasion. i just dont like how maidana threw an overhand right while amir was trying to show respect and tap gloves....

[tomjo]

Not a bad list at all to be honest.

[Pacquiao'd]

pac and all his glorious paper titles

[G Doggy Dog]

i love pac and want him to fight prime fighters also. but mayweather is the one not fighting period and last prime guy was hatton and before that?


i just havent seen floyd fight an ELITE prime fighter for a long time .... and no hatton was not elite

[G Doggy Dog]

Not bad at all G-dog

thanks spray

good ist G, i wouldnt have amir in top 10 just yet

it might be a lil soon but his boxing ability amazes me so much. watching him throw 3 punch combos like nothing and landing at will sometimes is incredible. i love watching amir fight.

[ikim322]

#1 Manny Pacquiao - Obvious reasons just won his 9th division or whatever

#2 Sergio Martinez - Catches Middleweight crown and defends it in awesome fashion against "the most feared boxer" in paul williams

#3 Floyd Mayweather - Has potential to be #1 but with inactivity and failure to fight fighters in they primes leaves this guy at #3

#4 Wladimir Klitschko - Dominating the HW division. ****** he had to pull out of his fight this weekend but would have been a win under his belt anyways.

#5 Juan Manuel Marquez - Still taxin dat ass at age 37 and is unbeatable at 135 right now. A move to 140 would be interesting, a fight with Zab Judah would be cool

#6 Jean Pascal - Beat former undefeated champ chad dawson in a close war. This guy has the tools to break top 5 in 2011

#7 Amir Khan - Put on a great performance against Marcos Maidana and proved the critics wrong. He took Marcos's best shots and never tasted the canvas once.

#8 Vitali Klitschko - Second best HW out there. Has arguebly never lost a round since coming out of retirement

#9 Andre Ward - Undefeated in the Super Six, he has what it takes to be top 5 in the coming years. Is the outright favourite to win super six

#10 Juan Manuel Lopez - This guy keeps woopin ass at 125, Hard pressed to say who will beat him any time soon.

That's a pretty good list.

Although I wouldn't quite place Pascal that high (fringe of top 10 at best I think). Same with Amir just yet. Maybe just outside the top 10 for now. With that said, it's tough to come up with more worthy guys I guess besides the winner of Donaire/Montiel. Those two are already on the bottom of some people's top 10 lists and the winner of that fight surely deserves decent spot.

I like the inclusion of the Klitschkos. 'Pound for Pound' isn't a term usually given to heavyweights but I don't see why the casual fan seem to just exclude them. Their body of work (boring or not) is without question and well...they just simply don't even lose rounds anymore. Not really their fault that there's not enough talented heavies. And that they're well coordinated giants with excellent jabs (first place you'd probably start in evaluating a boxer's skill). What more do people expect

[Pacquiao'd]

i love pac and want him to fight prime fighters also. but mayweather is the one not fighting period and last prime guy was hatton and before that?


i just havent seen floyd fight an ELITE prime fighter for a long time .... and no hatton was not elite

atleast floyd has fought a prime and even undefeated fighter. its been a long time since pac has fight a prime fighter...since JMM to be exact

[Boxin']

atleast floyd has fought a prime and even undefeated fighter. its been a long time since pac has fight a prime fighter...since JMM to be exact

How was Clottey not in his prime?

[G Doggy Dog]

atleast floyd has fought a prime and even undefeated fighter. its been a long time since pac has fight a prime fighter...since JMM to be exact

pfff undefeated dont mean **** if you dont face anybody. just becoz you have a loss doesnt make you a journeyman. ppl fall in love with UNDEFEATED records these days...