Top 5 most over rated fighters in the sport

[$tate of Mind]

1). Manny Pacquiao-currently the most over rated athelete in all of sports imo.

2). Paul Williams-this guy needs to learn how to use his height and avoid punches.

3). Lucian Bute-I like his skills, but he really lost the first Andrade fight, who has he beat Edison Miranda?

4). Celestino Caballero-looked terrible in his last fight, against a guy who had no business beating him.

5). Nonito Donaire-I really like him and his skills, but what has he done since beating Darchiniyan? I hope he gets a fight with Juan Manuel Lopez.

Honorable Mention: I really like all these guys but their relatively unproven and or inexperienced Victor Ortiz, Yuriorkis Gamboa, Devon Alexander

[$tate of Mind]

What do you guys think?

[Carpe Diem]

I respect your opinion, but i have to disagree with No.1 and No. 5.

[El Protagonista]

I respect your opinion, but i have to disagree with No.1 and No. 5.

Co-sign. I think Donaire is really only overrated by RING magazine. I don't really see alot of fans overrating him so I wouldn't put him there.

[The Hammer]

Most overrated:

1. Floyd Mayweather

2. Andre Ward

3. Andre Berto

4. Yuriorkis Gamboa

5. Guillermo Rigonderoux



Dawson, Caballero and Williams were also overrated, but not any more.

Haye is overrated by some people in the UK, but not in the US or elsewhere.

[$tate of Mind]

I respect your opinion, but i have to disagree with No.1 and No. 5.

Both guys are very good, but I think the media over hypes them. It's not their fault.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Most overrated:

1. Floyd Mayweather

2. Andre Ward

3. Andre Berto

4. Yuriorkis Gamboa

5. Guillermo Rigonderoux



Dawson, Caballero and Williams were also overrated, but not any more.

Haye is overrated by some people in the UK, but not in the US or elsewhere.

this looks about right

[Walt Liquor]

good list tunney, i'd have to disagree with floyd, only a real elite fighter can touch floyd more than once in a fight.

pwilly is not overrated. losing to sergio doesn't make him overrated and he has some damn good wins.

bute and ward should be considered about even. ward really hasn't done all that much but at least bute has looked spectacular.

haye is waaay overrated.

[$tate of Mind]

this looks about right

I'm glad you had the courage to actually show up in one of my threads

[$tate of Mind]

good list tunney, i'd have to disagree with floyd, only a real elite fighter can touch floyd more than once in a fight.

pwilly is not overrated. losing to sergio doesn't make him overrated and he has some damn good wins.

bute and ward should be considered about even. ward really hasn't done all that much but at least bute has looked spectacular.

haye is waaay overrated.

Who rates Haye highly?