Just re-watched Mayweather-Castillo 1

[G Doggy Dog]

This is the second time ive watched this fight and it BAFFLES me. Baffles me beyond beleif how Anek Hongtongkam scored this fight 116-111 for mayweather. im not hating on floyd either. At worst it should have been a Majority Decision for Castillo.

I respect floyd and his skills but he was not the better man that night. Jose Luis Castillo was robbed more than anything. And im not being a hater or biased. Its the TRUTH.

[-EAGLE-]

yea i had castillo by 1 round lolzz ^^

[Pacquiao'd]

haha. look at the haters. gorilla dog is back to being pissed and hating on floyd. hell be back on his **** soon, though

[G Doggy Dog]

haha. look at the haters. gorilla dog is back to being pissed and hating on floyd. hell be back on his **** soon, though

how am i hating on floyd? just becuz i think he lost the fight means im hating on him? when did i say he ******? get real

[The Gambler1981]

You do know what majority decision means right? That means 2 judges score it for 1 man while another scores it a draw.

If one man can score it a draw that means 3 men can have it a draw, as long as the right three men are watching and really from scoring it a draw, is having a couple rounds scored differently in a tough close fight that big a deal or even an issue.

Think about what you are saying

[ThunderWolf]

Ey g dog, how was you short stint as imaginary mod?

BTW, Floyd was under Arum that time vs Castillo??

[G Doggy Dog]

You do know what majority decision means right? That means 2 judges score it for 1 man while another scores it a draw.

If one man can score it a draw that means 3 men can have it a draw, as long as the right three men are watching and really from scoring it a draw it is having a coupel rounds scored differently in a tough close fight that big a deal.

Think about what you are saying

that is what im saying. it could have been scored a draw but Castillo won that fight. I know boxing and i know was a SD, MD, TD all that crap is

[Ishy Aytan]

Who cares? Theres loads of disputed fights in boxing. Plus Floyd did the right thing by giving him an immediate rematch.


You can go over fights over the past 10 years, and put polls up about disputed fights. Its happened, move on. Theres more closer decisions since the Mayweather-Castillo fight that are worth debating.

[The Gambler1981]

that is what im saying. it could have been scored a draw but Castillo won that fight. I know boxing and i know was a SD, MD, TD all that crap is

Obviously you don't, scores are based on the eye of the beholder if one guy scores it a draw then all 3 have a reasonable chance of doing the same.

All depends on who is scoring the fight and what they like.

As an aside losing 5 of the first 6 rounds is no way to win a decision, because that requires you to be perfect in the eyes of another man and that is an almost impossible task.

[letsgobrady]

that is what im saying. it could have been scored a draw but Castillo won that fight. I know boxing and i know was a SD, MD, TD all that crap is

did you have floyd win the 1st 4 rounds of the fight like everyone else in the world?because all floyd had to do was win 2 rounds after winning the 1st 4 and it's a draw so i don't know why everyon makes seem like he lost if anything the fight was a draw not a lost