Do you really consider Pac a legit 154 title holder?

[jrosales13]

No, of course he isn't.

[nomadman]

not unless he fights martinez

[AKATheMack]

Why is everybody acting like a bunch of bitches over another mans success? Most title holders today arent legit. Look at the title holders in every weight class right now and I bet you dont recognize half the fighters. The belt system is a joke. What Manny did was batter a man nobody would have given him a chance against 2 years ago. I have no doubt he could unify the titles against Cotto and Bundrage, but I have no desire to see it.

[Russian Crushin]

He either holds a title or he doesnt

What you are looking for is if he is the legit champ, and thats a no

[vegeta23]

your more of joke for thinking pac is the legit champ of 154

ok,who's better in a 154 division now?

[The Noose]

Pacs win was great, but how can he keep a straight face when they call him a JMW champ?

I guess boxing is a business, and being called a 8 weight champ makes for good promotion and more money.

He either holds a title or he doesnt

What you are looking for is if he is the legit champ, and thats a no

I was seeing if 'boxing fans' think him having the 154 belt is bull***** or not.

Seems like all the people who voted yes to him being a legit 154lber havent posted why.

Its just a shame such a great fighter undermines the sport and boxing fans with this sham of being a MW champ.

[Dempsey-Roll]

its great to see pac destroy margarito, but as for him being called a jmw champion................
some ppl may argue he beat marg when marg's at 165, hence, pac is fully capable destroying and fighting jmw boxers... hence... making him a jmw champion.......................................... .............................
........................
............................................

















































i'll get my coat

[AssasinKing]

Im a huge huge pac fan

But the fact is, to be a legit holder of a division, you have to be able to beat all the people in that division, and im not sure if pac can do that....

Not because hes not great...cos he is the best in the sport in my opinion....but hes just not big enough for that division, i still think he would beat 90% of the people in that division tho...

That just shows how great he really is

[ModernTalking]

I don't really agree with the 154 belt that Pac won because it was only a vacant belt. What I saw was Pac beating a good welterweight in Margarito...PAC was like,'hey I'll give you 3 extra pounds and we can still fight'. It was opportunity that was there and Pac took it, don't blame Pac but blame the WBC. PAC winning his 154 belt is more real than Oscar winning his 160 belt. PAC dominated a big welter who they fought within the Jr. Welterweight division. Oscar on the other hand lost his fight and was given the decision just so he could fight Hopkin.

[Russian Crushin]

Im a huge huge pac fan

But the fact is, to be a legit holder of a division, you have to be able to beat all the people in that division, and im not sure if pac can do that....

Not because hes not great...cos he is the best in the sport in my opinion....but hes just not big enough for that division, i still think he would beat 90% of the people in that division tho...

That just shows how great he really is

He cant beat k-9 and cotto? What belt holder can't he beat?