What's your take at Mayweather still at P4P No2??

[120]

Me personally am not a fan of inactivity and I don't think he deserves that rank. He fought 1 fight in '08, 1 in '09 and 1 in '10. And before anyone says anything, yes this is in regards to Sergio at the moment. Coming in with such great victories, he should be at No2 and Mayweather down to No3. And as people continue to have great victories, he should continue to move down or be taken out completely until he proves himself....

What you guys think? Please no trolling, lets have a serious discussion...

[chinoy]

im not a Floyd fan but i think he deserve slot #2 due to his destruction of Mosley a few months ago....

Martinez went up too fast....JMM should be #3, not Martinez.....

[FloydTBE]

in my view hes the best boxer on the planet. hopefully a fight with pac can get made in 2011 n then everyone will see

[120]

im not a Floyd fan but i think he deserve slot #2 due to his destruction of Mosley a few months ago....

Martinez went up too fast....JMM should be #3, not Martinez.....

based on what?

[bojangles1987]

He had a fight 8 months ago, which isn't nearly enough to say he's inactive. Knowing what might happen with him I understand people saying he is gone, but Mosley went twice as long between Margarito and Mayweather than Mayweather has gone since his last fight, and no one was removing him from p4p lists.

Mayweather is p4p clearly a better fighter than Sergio Martinez, so until Floyd is confirmed as gone or loses, he keeps the 2 spot.

[bojangles1987]

im not a Floyd fan but i think he deserve slot #2 due to his destruction of Mosley a few months ago....

Martinez went up too fast....JMM should be #3, not Martinez.....

Completely agree about Marquez. He has done nothing to be dismissed like he is on people's p4p lists. He's clearly the third best fighter in the world IMO.

[Shadow boxer 3]

so far its been 6 months. floyd normally fights once a year so this is nothing new. but at the moment floyd is the better fighter. 6 months of inactivity doesn't change that.

[120]

depends on how long his inactivity last IMO. so far its been 6 months. floyd normally fights once a year so this is nothing new.

yeah, but we all know that he's not getting in the ring anytime soon and rightfully so. With all this fiasco in his personal life, he's excused by me. But what I mean is that in the mean time, let us let the other players stack their cards and make it more interesting.

[Shadow boxer 3]

yeah, but we all know that he's not getting in the ring anytime soon and rightfully so. With all this fiasco in his personal life, he's excused by me. But what I mean is that in the mean time, let us let the other players stack their cards and make it more interesting.

i see what ur saying but even though floyd is inactive he's still a better fighter then sergio skill wise. so moving sergio up cause floyd is inactive at the moment is like moving him up on a technicality so to speak

[daggum]

why do people care about these ****** lists? it's clearly a popularity contest. floyd hasn't had an A level win since castillo yet he's still number 2. racking up B level wins over and over is good enough as long as you don't lose i suppose. come on sergio just hang tight and keep making easy fights till floyd and pac retire and you will accomplish your dream of being number 1!