Is Marquez taking on more dangerous fighters than manny!

[SNVDoublePunch!]

but retrospectivley, he's garbage.

even at his "peak" he wasn't a p4p match to Cotto imo.

No. He wasn't and isn't garbage. That's ridiculous. You don't unify three of the four major titles in your division, one at a time, or perform in a ring classic with a great fighter like Marquez if you're garbage. That's a ridiculous thing to say. Although, I agree he doesn't match Cotto.

[muppetman]

Could you say that when Marquez fought Juan Diaz the first time and Manny fought David Diaz? Yes. Was that argument shot to ****e when Manny started taking on Hatton and three of the five biggest names of the welterweight division in the past five years? Also yes. Don't be silly.

so your telling me margarito presented a more dangerous fight for pac at 150 than pac and lets say katsidis at 135 both of them at 135....no way!

[Ryn0]

Campbell was the lineal champ.. since he beat Diaz first.

Katsidis has been KO'd by Casamayor. Maybe if you take into account Marquez cannot fight at WW effectively he's taking dangeous fights for his size but if Pacquiao were to come across Diaz or Katsidis he would demolish them quickly.

[muppetman]

No. He wasn't and isn't garbage. That's ridiculous. You don't unify three of the four major titles in your division, one at a time, or perform in a ring classic with a great fighter like Marquez if you're garbage. That's a ridiculous thing to say. Although, I agree he doesn't match Cotto.

great point.

[maguirre]

i think so.....the fighters that Marquez has been facing seem to be more dangerous for manny than his latest oponents....theyve all seem to come off big losses....while marquez is always taking risks...katsisdis is a live fighter very live......when is the last time manny really had a live dawg to fight.....i even think manny would have got schooled bad by floyd.opinions please!

Riight. Tell him to fight Margarito and Cotto. I bet if he would even dream of fighting Clottey.

Riight.

;-)

[SNVDoublePunch!]

so your telling me margarito presented a more dangerous fight for pac at 150 than pac and lets say katsidis at 135 both of them at 135....no way!

No, I'm saying taking on Margarito at 150 is more dangerous to either Pacquiao or Marquez than Katsidis at 135, not Margarito is more dangerous FOR PACQUIAO than Katsidis is dangerous FOR MARQUEZ. You misunderstand.

[Earl-Hickey]

No. He wasn't and isn't garbage. That's ridiculous. You don't unify three of the four major titles in your division, one at a time, or perform in a ring classic with a great fighter like Marquez if you're garbage. That's a ridiculous thing to say. Although, I agree he doesn't match Cotto.

He lot twice to Paulie Maglinaggi.

hes ****e

[muppetman]

Riight. Tell him to fight Margarito and Cotto. I bet if he would even dream of fighting Clottey.

Riight.

;-)

hed do it for the same amount of mney pac made and the same ****** catchweights.....he would have done exactly what pac did to oscar and hatton!!

[SNVDoublePunch!]

Campbell was the lineal champ.. since he beat Diaz first.

Katsidis has been KO'd by Casamayor. Maybe if you take into account Marquez cannot fight at WW effectively he's taking dangeous fights for his size but if Pacquiao were to come across Diaz or Katsidis he would demolish them quickly.

NO. Campbell was not lineal champion because Diaz wasn't lineal champion. Diaz had the WBO, WBA and IBF titles. Which is impressive but it doesn't make you linear. The lineage went from Mayweather to Castillo to Corrales to Casamayor to Marquez.

[trainhard_187]

Katsidas, far from being dangerous.. and Juan Diaz? I guess you missed Nate Campbell schooling Diaz..

Pac slaughters both Diaz and Katsidas..

Put Marquez in Pacs shoes, Margarito, Clottey, and Cotto stop Marquez