Bigger win: Pac over Marg Or Martinez over Williams

[Phil Ivey]

LOL @ tough call, it's not even close. The fact that Margarito has looked unimpressive his last two fights and post plaster, the issue of him being the bigger man isn't a huge advantage it is made out to be. Fact is, Pac is an elite boxer and Marg is a C+ Grade fighter at best. Haye-Valuev was David and Goliath. Martinez was defending his title, absolutely demolished the 'most avoided fighter' in vintage fashion, oh and he was also on the p4p list unlike Margarito who was no where near any rankings at all.

[hugh grant]

What pac did was more impressive. To find a ko punch like Sergi did, when the other guy commited as well happens more often than not in boxing.

To do what pac did shows superior ability. Not even close. Pac is better.
PW is overrated anyway. He is the guy who is known for challenging than actually fighting. Most people would know PW for saying people wont fight him and challenging Pac at 147.

[eddiefutch]

Both were good fights but Martinez/Williams was more shocking......plus it was good to see Martinez even the score and leave no room for doubt this time.I like Pac,but was there really any doubt he would lose to Margarito?

[hugh grant]

Pacs win was better because for 12 rounds he showed superior ability. Sergio didnt show SUPERIOR ability. He landed a great punch. One punch versus Pacs 400, dont compare.

People say after the Sergio fight that it was a visually stunning knockout. For Pacs performance against Margarito, they were stunned by Pacs performance. I think Evander Holyfield said Pacs performance was sensational.

If the art of boxing is what rocks your boat than pacs performance will rock your boat. If you are a savage beast and like one punch knockouts, well......