Lets not forget shane did to tony what manny couldnt!!

[Anti~Jalandoni]

I cant stand this crap manny beats shane cuz shane look bad against Mora....mora and manny have two diffrent styles and way diffrent heights....mora is crafty!remeber manny couldnt stop tony ....shane did!!

Lets not forget what Pacquiao did to Cotto what Shane couldn't !

[ALG United]

I cant stand this crap manny beats shane cuz shane look bad against Mora....mora and manny have two diffrent styles and way diffrent heights....mora is crafty!remeber manny couldnt stop tony ....shane did!!

I am a big fan of Manny, and Shane as well, Shane did TKO'd Tony during the twilight of his career, Shane clearly was not as fast and agile as he was 5 yrs younger but his speed was enough and Shane still has that killer hooks when he defeated Margarito, and you have to consider they were at the WW level and Tony i think came in at 158-160lbs at fight night... Fast forward to Manny vs Tony, Manny is very well known as a combination power punches and he did fought a much heavier/healthier Margarito at 165lbs and I think Manny could have TKO'd Tony if only Manny didn't show any mercy at the last 2 rounds. But 1 fact is, Tony required some surgery in his right temple bone because of the sustained power punches to his eyes given by Manny, and if your gonna ask me which fighter did better against Tony? It's Manny hands down, Shane did TKO'd Tony but Tony was up and smiling a few seconds after that, while with Manny, Tony's face was busted in and out with tremendous danger to his eyes vision...

[muppetman]

Lets not forget, Manny did to Cotto what Shane couldn't!

Not only did he beat the guy that Shane couldn't,

he actually knocked him down and stopped him.


Going two and 0 against Cotto and Margarito>>>> 1-1.

Margarito ruined Cotto first if he had did it before the mosley fight then mosley would have stoped him too...so thats a bad point cuz cotto was already damaged...probably worse than what manny did...The cotto that fought mosley was a wayyyy diffrent cotto...he was cotto the Machine!!

[DarchinyFAN]

if u wanna base fights off like that then manny will murder floyd since manny destroyed hatton and oscar, 2 opponents floyd beat.

Not to meantion Pac battered Cotto who beat Shane.......

[Ryannn]

Manny beats Shane because Manny is the better fighter and Shane is not what he once was.

The fight should not happen at all.

Pac will be cherry picking if he fights Shane.

co-sign...

manny has nothing to gain if he fights mosley.

[muppetman]

Not to meantion Pac battered Cotto who beat Shane.......

look at my post above you!!