Sportinglife pound-for-pound world top 10

[ThunderWolf]

Sportinglife.com pound-for-pound world top 10:

1 Manny Pacquiao

2 Floyd Mayweather

3 Juan Manuel Marquez

4 Miguel Cotto

5 Bernard Hopkins

6 Sergio Martinez

7 Shane Mosley

8 Yuriorkis Gamboa

9 Juan Manuel Lopez

10 Nonito Donaire

Honourable mentions: Andre Ward, Paul Williams, Timothy Bradley, Wladimir Klitschko and Fernando Montiel.

http://www.sportinglife.com/boxing/news/story_get.cgi?STORY_NAME=boxing/10/11/22/manual_212005.html

[rochemback]

Not a bad list in my opinion.
Cotto is a bit high, Gamboa is more ranked by potential than by actual achievement and my main quarrel is Hopkins, who I would not have in my top10 anymore. Some will have a problem with Mosley in that list, but I believe he is still a top10-15 fighter.

[niallcollins]

Sportinglife.com pound-for-pound world top 10:

1 Manny Pacquiao

2 Floyd Mayweather

3 Juan Manuel Marquez

4 Miguel Cotto

5 Bernard Hopkins

6 Sergio Martinez

7 Shane Mosley

8 Yuriorkis Gamboa

9 Juan Manuel Lopez

10 Nonito Donaire

Honourable mentions: Andre Ward, Paul Williams, Timothy Bradley, Wladimir Klitschko and Fernando Montiel.

http://www.sportinglife.com/boxing/n...al_212005.html

that p4p list is ****.martinez shud be in 3rd..
if bhop is in the top 10 im surprised audley harrison didnt get an honourable mention ha ha

[Tamis!]

that p4p list is ****.martinez shud be in 3rd..
if bhop is in the top 10 im surprised audley harrison didnt get an honourable mention ha ha

Let's see your list if you feel strongly opposed of that list.

[apollocreed]

mosley no way - he was dominated by floyd, then drew with mora?? his days in the p4p 10 are over.

apart from that pretty similar to mine, apart from i wouldn't have lopez in there either, i think he's over rated. i'd have jean pascal in there, plus maybe bradley and chad dawson. dawsons stock has plummeted since losing to pascal, but i think he will redeem himself. he didn't prepare properly and it was a close fight when it was stopped. i'd say b hop still deserves the benefit of the doubt atm, but we will see if he still deserves to be in there when he fights pascal.

[apollocreed]

My List:

1 Manny Pacquiao

2 Floyd Mayweather

3 Sergio Martinez

4 Juan Manuel Marquez

5 Bernard Hopkins

6 Miguel Cotto

7 Jean Pascal

8 Yuriorkis Gamboa

9 Nonito Donaire

10 Chad Dawson

Honourable mentions: Andre Ward, David Haye, Timothy Bradley, Wladimir Klitschko and Fernando Montiel

[ELHURACAN58]

My List:

1 Manny Pacquiao

2 Floyd Mayweather

3 Sergio Martinez

4 Juan Manuel Marquez

5 Bernard Hopkins

6 Miguel Cotto

7 Jean Pascal

8 Yuriorkis Gamboa

9 Nonito Donaire

10 Chad Dawson

Honourable mentions: Andre Ward, David Haye, Timothy Bradley, Wladimir Klitschko and Fernando Montiel

I agree with this list except the last three.

Id put Juanma instead of Gamboa for his two division belts, and better opposition faced.

Id demote Nonito Donaire to number ten to put Wladimir Klitschko in number 9, as Wladimir has done more pound 4 pound stuff than Donaire, who has lacked good opposition recently.

[WladIsTheChamp]

****ty list if they don't have Wladimir in it.

[apollocreed]

chris john deserves an honourable mention too! i always forget about him! not in the top 10 unless he fights lopez or gamboa tho.

[Deep Blue 1997]

Sportinglife.com pound-for-pound world top 10:

1 Manny Pacquiao

2 Floyd Mayweather

3 Juan Manuel Marquez

4 Miguel Cotto

5 Bernard Hopkins

6 Sergio Martinez

7 Shane Mosley

8 Yuriorkis Gamboa

9 Juan Manuel Lopez

10 Nonito Donaire

Honourable mentions: Andre Ward, Paul Williams, Timothy Bradley, Wladimir Klitschko and Fernando Montiel.

http://www.sportinglife.com/boxing/n...al_212005.html

****ty list if they don't have Wladimir in it.

True. I mean Cotto is way up there, Bernard has not looked that impressive lately either. and Sergio Martinez just above Mosley? ...i dont think so.

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Sergio Martinez
4. Wlad Klit
5. Vitali Klit
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Fernando Montiel
8. Lucian Bute
9. Timothy Bradley
10. Juan Manuel Lopez // Andre Ward

I understand, they are the bigger names in the sport.

but some of these guys in the list just have not been as impressive