Fighter of the Year... Manny or Sergio?

[puga]

******* here but i think sergio deserves it more ...

[Maidana vs Rios]

Sexy by a mile

[zeidrich]

sergio would get it, he deserve the award this year... pac on a close 2nd

[Iceta Lives]

Martinez, and easily. Pavlik and Williams?

Or Clottey coming off a loss or Margarito who...got brutally knocked out, kicked out of boxing for a year and fought a nobody.

Not even close.

I'd give it to Sergio, but beating Pavlik isn't really all that either when you stop to think about it. He'd already been brutalized by Hopkins and then beat Rubio (Who?) after pulling out of those fights against Williams and was inactive. Pavlik did have a 2 fight win streak going into the Martinez fight though didn't he? I can't remember the name of the second guy he beat though. The fact that he was still the legit Champ at Middleweight and undefeated in that division held some clout though.

[El Chicano]

At this point, I think Sergio vs Manny is a more competitive fight than vs Floyd. Floyd is quickly becoming a has been. Sergio needs just one big mainstream PPV fight just to get that mainstream attention then a fight vs Manny would be the shiznit... I say Sergio vs Margarito, Cotto or Chavez on PPV... then a mega fight with Manny at Dallas Stadium sometime late next year. What a fight!

[.Sakuragi.]

Sergio Martinez hands down.

[woweezowee]

sergio martinez easily

[Reloaded]

I'd give it to Sergio, but beating Pavlik isn't really all that either when you stop to think about it. He'd already been brutalized by Hopkins and then beat Rubio (Who?) after pulling out of those fights against Williams and was inactive. Pavlik did have a 2 fight win streak going into the Martinez fight though didn't he? I can't remember the name of the second guy he beat though. The fact that he was still the legit Champ at Middleweight and undefeated in that division held some clout though.

Pavlik was better than both Clottey and ****** out in a monster ring Margo ,, Sergio should get this no problems .

[El Chicano]

Sergio Martinez hands down.

sergio martinez easily

Manny vs Sergio !?!?

FOTD vs FOTY ?!?!

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

Pac on a close 2nd?

**** NO

Juan Manuel Lopez > Manny Pacquiao THIS YEAR.