Rating Floyd's Win Over Oscar?

[Perfect Plex]

Just how much of a great win was this?

Is it underrated?

It was Floyd first & only fight @ 154lb there were no cacthweights and Oscar was WBC Champion. He was 1-1-1 in is last 3, coming off a win over Ricrado Mayorga a year ago.

[Perfect Plex]

....................................

[Walterson]

I think it was very underated, but you know how things are? people are always looking for a way to discredit Mayweather Jr.

[Canelo Phresh]

haters discredit but it was a legit win over the # ranked jr middle weight champion with out a catchweight

[Kagami Taiga]

it was a good win. not great bu definitely good. its def better than pac's win over margarito at "154". altho im sure there will be ppl who argue otherwise for their own reasons.

[puga]

it was an ok win, but his perfromnce put people to sleep!....not to mention he won by SD!

[AKATheMack]

It was a good win. It was a win over a fighter who was past prime and probably couldnt have beat him prime for prime, but a very good win nonetheless.

[jrosales13]

Eh......... It was a 6 or a 7...

It is not even one of Floyd top 5 best win... Maybe somewhere lower in the top 10 if it makes the top 10.

I wasn't impressed at all....

[Century Tuna]

Mayweather is a pure boxer where Pacquiao is not. ... Mayweather is the best

[Kagami Taiga]

Mayweather is a pure boxer where Pacquiao is not. ... Mayweather is the best

wtf does this have to do with the thread???