Where is Manny Pacquiao in your Top ATG list?????

[madsweeney]

Top 30 I suppose? I base my rankings on in ring performance, achievements, and dominance. There has been way to much controversy in Pacquiao's career. I rank him right next to Rocky Marciano. He's basically the newer generation of Rocky.

Sugar Ray Robinson
Muhammad Ali
Sugar Ray Leonard
George Foreman
Henry Armstrong
Roy Jones Jr
Marvin Hagler
Lennox Lewis
Bernard Hopkins
Joe Louis
Floyd Mayweather Jr
Willie Pep
Julio Cesar Chavez
Joe Frazier
Sugar Shane Mosley
Archie Moore
Oscar De La Hoya
Marco Antonio Barrera
Larry Holmes
Pernell Whitaker
Winky Wright
Evander Holyfield
Thomas Hearns
Felix Trinidad
Erik Morales
Mike Tyson
Alexis Arguello
Juan Manuel Marquez
Prince Naseem Hamed
Manny Pacquiao
Rocky Marciano

Haven't you ever heard the saying "Its better for people to think your a fool, than to speak and remove all doubt"?!?

[SplitSecond]

top 10 no doubt

[joelab75]

The difference between Zab Judah and Manny Pacquiao is, Zab Judah IMO is one of the fastest fighters I've ever seen. His potential was wasted. Stop overhyping Pacquiao. The guy is getting FAR TOO MUCH Credit for what he has done in the sport of boxing. He's been given gimmie fights throughout his whole career. Juan Manuel Marquez was his big test, and in most peoples opinion's Marquez won the 2nd fight. Goes to show how good you compare to the Pacquiao that fought David Diaz to the Pacquiao that fought Marquez.



20 years huh? Bull****. Roy Jones Jr is the best boxer I've ever seen in the 90s, the problem was with Jones the same for Manny. Jones was given alot of gimmie fights to make him look good. However Jones left a legacy, Manny is a box office attraction. Huge difference.

Historians as in the fools on ESPN and the guys on HBO who are paid to make Pacquiao look good? Yeah I'll believe them sure.

coming from a guy who put Morales, Barrera and Mosley above Manny.
Zab aint sheet. Zab was overrated, overhype average boxer. put him with Manny he will look worst than Margarito. same goes with ur Floydie.

[RockStar45]

I voted him Top 30 for now.

It's hard to judge him rationally and compare him with older greats with all the excitement from his last fight and also because he's a polarizing figure right now (at least to Mayweather fans). There's a reason why there's a waiting period for Hall of Fame voting.

Time will tell, but I think most boxing fans will agree Pacquiao certainly one of the best fighters they've ever seen.

[Las Vegas,]

Freddie Roach wants Marquez again at 147. Hmm, yeah that's a joke and yet another controversy in Pacquiao's infamous career.

[Las Vegas,]

I voted him Top 30 for now.

It's hard to judge him rationally and compare him with older greats with all the excitement from his last fight and also because he's a polarizing figure right now (at least to Mayweather fans). There's a reason why there's a waiting period for Hall of Fame voting.

Time will tell, but I think most boxing fans will agree Pacquiao certainly one of the best fighters they've ever seen.

No doubt about it. He is one of the best fighters I've ever seen. His competition on the other hand...

[joelab75]

No doubt about it. He is one of the best fighters I've ever seen. His competition on the other hand...

his opponents are way better than your self proclaimed greatest ever. if a 38 yrs Mosley was Floyd's biggest win his career is a BIG JOKE. Cotto beat a better version of Mosley. Cotto can beat any of Mayweather's opponent. Cotto was not even Manny's best win.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

^ That................

[infamous larryx]

once again how can you rank a person without having an actual list?

[heat27]

top 40......