Pacquiao HAS to be top 5 ATG

[Wukillabeez78]

One, Martinez didn't KO Margarito (He lost actually).

Two, Diego Corrales was significantly bigger than him

Now what u said about May's only acceptable fight other than Pac being against the Martinez/Williams winner. I agree

Thanks for correcting me!

[Check_hooks]

Pac is top 3 p4p, back in the day you had alot of top fighters that couldnt carry Pac's jock strap

[xzworks]

pacquiao need to beat mayweather first..

[puga]

dont be afraid ts, experts have been regarding pac as top 5 atg even before this fight!....no need to hold back!

[kill4]

Victories over Ledwaba, Marquez, Morales, Barrera, De la Hoya, Hatton, Cotto, Clottey and Margarito don't lie. The way he beat them, and his ascension through the weight classes is what makes it so special, yeah Margarito isn't Joe Louis, but he is a big, solid world champion class volume puncher who couldn't win a round with Pacquiao in his EIGHTH (granted there are alot of them these days) weight class, and I think that speaks for itself. I'm not a Floyd hater, but I am sick of his woulda, coulda shoulda, hes talked **** about Clottey, Margarito, Cotto, Williams, etc, meanwhile Manny Has been pounding on most of these guys. I think the Mayweather-Marquez fight was a circus, but i give Floyd credit for a solid win over Mosley, although that fight should have happened after Mosley first moved back down to welter. If Maywetaher wants to make an impression and really fight for the p4p crown he needs to beat Pac, or the Winner of Martinez-Williams, and he needs to do it convincingly.

Well said! i for one thought that pac would have some trouble with marg because of the big weight difference.. That just didn't happen. I as a boxing fan am not a strict fan of one boxer. I do favor pac tho over all of the current boxers (not with prejudice). I look at things logically, and i got to say i thought manny would have some trouble with marg.. but that didnt happen as i said above. Dude performed very well, and has amazed me once again.

Dude is one of the best for sure.. There is no dought.. Anyone that says less is fooling themselves my two cents..

[Dempsey's Fan]

Its not that Pacquiao beat Margarito (in his eight weight class) that makes him a candidate for top 5 ATG, its that he pounded on Margarito, AND Clottey AND Hatton AND De La Hoya AND Cotto, etc etc. People love to talk shot about Manny but name one thing he has done recently which wasnt noteworthy, or at least admirable? Who else should he have been fighting once the Mayweather fight collapsed then guys, im curious. Martinez and Williams, or someone solid at 140 are the only other options which would be memorable.

[puga]

i knew this would happen, lol....this happens after every pacquiao fight.....pacquiao beats a flat-footed/slow fighter at a catch-weight and *******s act as if he pulled a buster douglas.

lame......

i know this would happen too, every pac fight , *****s come in to discredit pac...lol

lame....

[jaestix1]

i know this would happen too, every pac fight , *****s come in to discredit pac...lol

lame....

there is nothing to discredit because poochiao doesn't deserve any credit for this fight.

[kill4]

i know this would happen too, every pac fight , *****s come in to discredit pac...lol

lame....

Ninja you drunk..

[Dempsey's Fan]

there is nothing to discredit because poochiao doesn't deserve any credit for this fight.

Who should he have fought, given that Mayweather couldn't reach a negotiation? Vitali? Why cant you give a great fighter credit for dominating a good fighter? Tonight's fight was much more entertaining than Mayweather-Marquez, and about as meaningful as Mayweather-Mosley, maybe a bit more so just because of the unprecedented move up in weight i'd say. Overall a good night of boxing, much to Pacquiao's and Margarito's credit, why you hating?