Comments Thread For: If Margarito Wins, He Moves From Shame To Hall of Fame

[FloydTBE]

so i guess you dont want to see pac vs floyd then?

hell yeah i do, but iv gotta support the fighter i want to win. Pac will pribs win, but id like to see marg pull off the upset

[Dave Rado]

Why did Michael Marley bring up the Douglas-Tyson fight? Douglas is not in the Hall of Fame! One win doesn't make you a hall of famer.

It did in the case of Max Schmeling though. His only good win was against Louis. (I don't count the DQ win against Sharkey).

[Cafe]

[antrob]

It did in the case of Max Schmeling though. His only good win was against Louis. (I don't count the DQ win against Sharkey).

Same thing with Ken Norton because of his victory over Ali. But the Hall of Fame has gotten it's act together over the past couple of years and it's harder to get in, as it should be.

[gibo]

If Margarito wins, which he should, being so much bigger and stronger than Pacquiao, still doesn't make him HOF material. He'll needs to defeat SSM, who almost killed him, in a rematch. And defeat COTTO again in the same manner he won the first fight. Beating PAC only means he beat a small ATG. Not rematching SSM or COTTO, shows that the wraps were indeed intact!!!!

[Check_hooks]

just cuz margarito wins doesnt change the fact that he tried to cheat by loading his gloves. he will always be a dirty stinky scumbag cheater.

[boxingfan76]

If Marg wins, you can't compare it to the Duglas upset. It's not even close. I believe it makes him a strong candidate though. Especially if he has afew more good wins.

it automatically does it should anyway margs has faced far stiffer competetion than manny has, marg came up the hard way manny came up the star way, big difference in opposition faced ,timing is everything in boxing.

[Cotto 54/10]

No, Margarcheato definitely does not deserve it.

[Biolink]

Thank God someone mentioned it was a Marley article. I don't want to contribute the penny or whatever he gets paid per view of his articles.

Seriously if Margarito upsets Pacquiao it is what it is. For some reason I'm doubting Buster Douglas will ever make it into the Hall of Fame despite beating Mike Tyson

[KingOfTheRng]

Hell NO does not make him hall of fame material IF and I mean IF he beats pacman then he would have to fill in where the question marks are beat cotto WITHOUT plaster and who ever else is questioned! THEN he can be a candidate. He may beat pac but I know he won't win the cotto rematch pacman and tony could care less about either one both are cheaters to me one is a catch weight fighter (which I know is okay but he fights every one at the weight he wants which is bull to me hes no 7 time champion hes a catch weight title holder) & tony you know his story. Not watching the lame fight