If Cotto, Mayweather, Hatton were at 140 today?!

[Mojita]

With the "tournament" going with Bradley, Khan, Maidana, Alexander, Ortiz..**** even Kotelnik. Who you think wins the whole set-up?

We're assuming Hatton is going to be in his prime, Cotto is not weight-drained yet and Mayweather is...Mayweather.

In the end I'd have Mayweather ontop [which would have added a big boost to his legacy] but to be honest, i don't think he'd even fight anyone but Khan or Hatton there.

I'd have Cotto > Bradley, Alexander, Khan [I'd believe Cotto has enough boxing ablity to get to Khan and more than enough power to KO him], Kotelnik.

Cotto = Maidana [Maidana probably could KO Cotto], Ortiz [It's a tossup fight, really don't know who wins]

Cotto < Hatton [MAYBE], Mayweather

you get the point..

what do you think?

[wazaa.]

Mayweather > Cotto > Khan > Bradley > Alexander > Hatton > Kotelnik > Maidana > Ortiz

[bojangles1987]

Mayweather is the clear tops, Cotto is second, then Bradley, then either Khan or Hatton. Everyone else is irrelevant.

[koboxer]

Mayweather > Cotto > Khan > hatton > Bradley > kotelnik > Alexander > Maidana > Ortiz

[daggum]

mayweather had his own 140 tournament with corley, bruseles and gatti. guess who won? thats right undefeated baby!

[infamous larryx]

floyd beats them all..i think at 140 floyd looked terrific and still packed alot of power and threw fluid combos..it would be him and cotto in the finals

[-PANDA-]

Floyd>Cotto>Ortiz>Khan>Hatton?>?Bradley>Kotelnik>Alexander>Maidana

not sure if a prime hatton would beat a prime bradley hence the questionmarks

[infamous larryx]

floyd>cotto>khan>bradley>hatton>alexander>ortiz

[-PANDA-]

floyd beats them all..i think at 140 floyd looked terrific and still packed alot of power and threw fluid combos..it would be him and cotto in the finals

he packed decent power...not a lot of power

cotto packed a lot of power at 140

[Foolkiller]

I think that Bradley has the balls to beat Floyd at 140, I would definitely have enjoyed that fight. The other matter is that some of these guys may still not have peaked at 140. I think that if Khan develops more he may have the right style and attributes to give Floyd troubles, none of the others beats Floyd (and I'll point out that I'm not exactly saying these two would either).