Comments Thread For: Ch-ch-changes- BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[PEBBLES!]

Good list.

[jrosales13]

List is legit. Especially the number one and two spots.

Good list but juan manuel lopez deserves to be up there especially when he ko rafa in foty

Who would you take out to put Juanma in?

bradley doesnt deserve a spot yet, if he beats alexander convincingly he does

martinez should be ranked above williams

ward should be included, lopez should as well, maybe donaire

I disagree with damn near everything you said

the guy who made this list is as f u c k ing idiot!

Yea OK

i make the argument that cotto and clottey are tougher fights than a 38 year old 16 month inactive former steroid user shane mosley, is this list for real or are boxing scene's writers getting more and more dumb by the day?

The top 2 are interchangeable. There is no right or wrong with the top 2. You can go either way with Floyd or Pac. I think is dumb to say there is a clear best. When they really isn't. And, is just a matter of preference anyways.

Holy hell Montiel and Moreno got bumped.

I wouldn't put Montiel above Paul Williams, and I'd have Andre Ward on there before Moreno. Other than that, I think it's clear the top 3 fighters in the world are Pac, Mayweather, and Marquez, and after that a lot of guys have a case.

IMO Moreno has done more and had beaten better opponents than Ward has. And, Moreno is doing it in a tougher, better, deeper division. But, due to the S6 right now is not as high profile as a division as 168 is. But, Moreno has done more than Ward has.

[Gratide]

tHAT'S BIGGEST PILE OF CRAP i'VE SEEN IN A WHILE! MANNY AND JMM SHOULD BE 1&2 , PBF WHO IS ON VACATION SHOULD TAKE A VACATION FROM THE DAMN LIST.
RING MAGAZINE HAS IT RIGHT , SEEMS THIS RAG WILL LET JUST ANYBODY WRITE CRAP AND POST IT . FLOYD IS COWARD AND DOES NOT DESERVE TO BE MENTIONED AS ANYTHING BUT A DAMN COWARD !

[jrosales13]

tHAT'S BIGGEST PILE OF CRAP i'VE SEEN IN A WHILE! MANNY AND JMM SHOULD BE 1&2 , PBF WHO IS ON VACATION SHOULD TAKE A VACATION FROM THE DAMN LIST.
RING MAGAZINE HAS IT RIGHT , SEEMS THIS RAG WILL LET JUST ANYBODY WRITE CRAP AND POST IT . FLOYD IS COWARD AND DOES NOT DESERVE TO BE MENTIONED AS ANYTHING BUT A DAMN COWARD !

BoxingScene list > Ring list don't be ridiculous.

Don't let your hatred or fan boyism get the best of you.

[Medved]

I have no problem with a heavyweight being in a PFP list if he is dominant AND if the division is deep with tough competition.

That is not case with today's heavyweights so Klitschko doesn't belong.

Heavy


Vitali Klitschko


David Haye


Wladimir Klitschko


Wladimir Klitschko


Wladimir Klitschko


Look at the number of belts they have and the number of times they defended that belt, theres nobody on the champions list that even comes close to what the brothers have done, Haye is going to lose his belt next if he ever finds the balls to fight his mandatory or one of the K brothers. He has defended it what once? now hes scared to fight his mandatory? While the brothers have tons of defenses and fight their mandatory along with ANYONE who wants to get into the ring with them.

We haven't had HW's this dominant and hungry for the unification of titles in a long time.

[ChopperRead]

The stuff about Wlad's losses is kind of amusing when you consider that Lennox Lewis was knocked cold by two journeymen, and yet it didn't seem to impact his rep that much at all.

I also wouldn't call Haye's win over Valuev "solid." He barely eked that fight out -- many think he didn't even do that -- and set a record for low punch output in the process.

[Pullcounter]

I'm fine with floyd ahead considering neither have yet to step in the ring thus far.

jmm is way too high up there at #3. beating juan diaz can't have bumped him all the way back up to 135 lbs. maybe after a few more dominating wins at lightweight will I consider it.

montiel is also way to high at #4. he was getting outboxed easily by hasagawa and if montiel is up here so should hasagawa.

martinez should be before pwill.

[Pullcounter]

what's with the "ch-ch-changes" bit??? is that a knock on dawson for his stuttering?

[lfc19titles]

How can you have floyd at number 1 when he is ducking the number 2 guy?

[bojangles1987]

IMO Moreno has done more and had beaten better opponents than Ward has. And, Moreno is doing it in a tougher, better, deeper division. But, due to the S6 right now is not as high profile as a division as 168 is. But, Moreno has done more than Ward has.

I won't disagree, but I like Ward and I'm kind of jumping the gun with him.