More Skilled, Calzaghe or Cotto?

[llamas1]

I think Cotto is a perfect fundamental fighter and really enjoyed watching him in his early career but has to say that Joe C is a bit of a Quandary. It almost seems that these no reason why he should be as good as he is.... But he is.

I just can't imagine why he's never been tagged with all that clowning around.

[mannyman]

A bit of a random comparison.

I'd say Cotto has better text book skill i.e. great jab and stance with a classic 'high' guard. However I'd say Calzaghe was the better overall skilled fighter - he was very unorthodox but had awesome hand speed and movement.

[mannyman]

Cotto. Atleast he knew how to throw a proper punch, unlike Calzaghe.

[daggum]

hands down(get it heh) this guy