Bernard Hopkins vs James Toney @ 168 primes

[boxasmash]

Who would win 1 on 1, who is more "old school" and who has the better defence?

[KickAzz]

toney at his best would beat hopkins.

have said that, toney is a huge let down despite all his skills, and hopkins in his prime always delievered, even in an ugly fight.

toney at his worst loses to hopkins.

[IMDAZED]

Oyy...such a tough fight. I think I give JT the slight edge here. He did everything a little better than B-Hop and would probably edge a decision.

[Dambala]

Hard to tell, but I'd pick Toney. Hopkins was way more active than now when he was on his prime but at 168 Toney would've beat him, his counterpunching skills were something crazy. I think it would've been close but Toney would've rallied on the later rds to win a UD.

[Low_ki]

Toney would win imo, I wanna see this fight now. Bhop says he wants to fight heavyweight,**** fight Toney for starters, it could have great build up seeing as they both hate each other.

[THE REED]

No bias from Natas in the polls

[THE REED]

Oyy...such a tough fight. I think I give JT the slight edge here. He did everything a little better than B-Hop and would probably edge a decision.

Except dieting.

[Pin Galarga]

Toney beats everyone in this division.. if we could keep him away from those Bar-Q joints and the Burgers, I can't see anyone beating him.

[-EX-]

Hopkins KO1 Toney


































Ya'll know I'm kidding...but I can't choose against Bernard although Toney's a great fighter in his own right...Hopkins by SD...

[JayDee2700]

Toney beats everyone in this division.. if we could keep him away from those Bar-Q joints and the Burgers, I can't see anyone beating him.

Yea right!!! You telln me James Toney at his best could beat Roy Jones at his best!? Plz Roy n his prime>Any1 in his divison