Mayweather - 6th Greatest Pound for Pound (All-Time)

[Chups]

I agree and approve this list.

[tanibanana]

Going by this logic...

1. Jimmy Barry 58 - 0
2. Ricardo Lopez 51 - 0 - 1
3. Rocky Marciano 49 - 0
4. Edson Pedro Nascimento 47 - 0
5. Joe Calzhage 46-0
6. Chris John 43-0
7. Samson Dutch Boy Gym 43-0
8. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. 41-0
9. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 41-0
10. Sven Ottke 34 - 0

[Bring It On]

finally a list you cannot dispute. facts!

Yup, Calzaghe > Floyd FOR SURE.

[zeidrich]

great list..... 100% agree

[Afactor4]

Awful list... No Spadafora or Joe Mesi... I'm in shock and awe.

LOL

[daggum]

ricardo lopez has a draw so i don't think he should be on the list. this is an outrage.

[minasyan]

great list nonito donaire should be #2 though

[frankisdead]

you forgot the greatest HW in the game today Zsolt Erdei
31-0

[BennyST]

Most Overrated Scum Ever (According to Gayweather's definition of "Greatness"):

1. Sugar Ray Robinson (not undefeated)
2. Muhammad Ali (not undefeated)
3. Henry Armstrong (not undefeated)
4. Manny Pacquiao (not undefeated)
5. Willie Pep (not undefeated)
6. Roberto Duran (not undefeated)
7. Archie Moore (not undefeated)
8. Joe Louis (not undefeated)
9. Harry Greb (not undefeated)
10. Sam Langford (not undefeated)

Why the **** have you got Pac fourth? Above Duran, Pep, Moore, Louis, Greb and Langford?

I dig the first list, but this is just as bad if you have Pac fourth ATG and are serious.

Christ.....Oh, and you forgot Harry Simon 28-0, two division world champion. Beat Winky Wright for the JMW title and undefeated Armand Kranjc for the MW title.

[BennyST]

I read a lot of article about the POUND FOR POUND.

But then, I can't find a single sentence nor items explaining the "CRITERIA"
in the selection for the Best POUND FOR POUND Boxer/Fighter.

What's the real meaning of Pound for Pound?

Undefeated Boxers only?

With the highest percentage of KO/TKO wins?

Achieved World Record of the most number of weight divisions title?

It's everything. Most important is opponents beaten and accomplishments over the course of a career.

Typically, the best have: Beaten great champion/HOF level opposition in their primes, dominated a single division, won titles or beaten great champions across a number of divisions, proved their greatness through longevity (fighting at the top for a long period of time), shown they can come back from losses and adversity and the skills with which they won and fought.

Obviously there are many more factors that come into play but these are the basic ones.