Watch this and tell me if you think Cotto could have beat Floyd in 05/06

[The Badguy]

Everybody knows Cotto has a weak chin... he's always been a good boxer, not a great one....

[-EX-]

I never thought Cotto would beat Floyd but I did want to see it..

A win over Cotto would look real good on Floyd's resume despite where Cotto is right now...

I think Miguel is too slow and a lil too easy to hit...and Floyd at 140 still threw combinations...

[Biolink]

Its not about "if"

People looking to discredit Floyd, will just say that the fight never happened so we'll never know.

And for the record I never believed Cotto would beat Mayweather. Especially at 140

[KickAzz]

Everybody knows Cotto has a weak chin... he's always been a good boxer, not a great one....

floyd always wins fantasy fights. so floyd doesn't ever have to actually fight anyone. it's called "the art of fighting without fighting".

[MrRolltide91]

if they would have fought, manny win over cotto wouldn't have been that good.

[The Badguy]

Man leave that Pac **** out of this... I'm being serious. Cotto get wobbled in every fight...

[starkiller]

The Cotto that fought Judah would give Mayweather problems and possibly beat him *2007 Cotto vs 2007 Mayweather jr.) . I think that was the best version of Cotto I ever seen, even though he was wobbled in that fight and arguably hurt. He still fought a very disciplined beautiful fight. Mayweather Jr. was never known as a very hard puncher at 147 anyways, unless it was against midget Hatton.

[KickAzz]

floyd has to actually fight and beat cotto to get any credit. a fantasy fight just doesn't cut it.

[Doctor_Tenma]

A great fight that was. Anyway, I never thought he could beat Mayweather, but Cotto chances would be a lot better at 147, he had problems making 140.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

08 was when the fight was hot and Mayweather retired.