rank morales, barrera, pacquiao & marquez in regards to their greatness...

[talip bin osman]

no nuthugging & hating please... be objective & respect ur fellow poster's opinion...

[Khalid X]

1. Pacquiao
2. Morales
3. Barrera
4 Marquez

Pacquiao is the only one to have wins over all three so he takes the number 1 spot. I gave Morales the nod over Barrera because Morales beat two of MAB conquerors. Also all three fights in the EM vs MAB trilogy were pretty close on could have went either way.

[talip bin osman]

no nuthugging & hating please... be objective & respect ur fellow poster's opinion...

im a manny pacquiao super-fan but i rate morales above him... (paumanhin mga kapatid...)

[tesla_power]

im a manny pacquiao super-fan but i rate morales above him... (paumanhin mga kapatid...)

Red k'd.

J/K pre.

Anyhow, pac ... morales ... mab ... jmm

Jmm is still going. If he even gets a belt at 140, I'd reconsider this. Morales/Mab are just about done and I hate Morales comeback now. What do you make of it? It just seems him and barrera are chasing that 4th title now.

Morales over Mab just because he made one of the murderous run facing one top guy to the other and capped it with a with over Pac even though he was slightly past it.

Pac IMO number of lineal titles outweighs anything those 3 got. And he got them by beating the number 1 in those division. I rest my case kapatid. Would not even mention the paper belt at 135.

[Georgeshills]

pacquiao, morales, Barrera, JMM.

Morales is a fighter, even if it got him Knocked out in his last two fights with pacquiao. Barrera's last fight with Pacquiao where he just ran around to survive puts a question mark in his legacy. JMM wasn't impressive with his last two fights, with Mayweather he was way over his head, and with Diaz I was expecting him to KO Diaz.

[Phil Ivey]

Pac, Morales, Barrera, JMM. I would of liked to see JMM vs Morales, I think JMM is the most resilient one out of Morales and Barrera, also gave Pac two very tough fights.

[Ryannn]

1. Pacquiao
2. Morales
3. Barrera
4 Marquez

Pacquiao is the only one to have wins over all three so he takes the number 1 spot. I gave Morales the nod over Barrera because Morales beat two of MAB conquerors. Also all three fights in the EM vs MAB trilogy were pretty close on could have went either way.

this......

[prometheuslord]

pac's easy to place. morales and barrera are pretty evenly matched, but in my eyes barrera takes it by a hair cause of his wins over morales in the trilogy and the epic takedown of naseem hamed. marquez is interesting... i think he would have a better than 50% chance of beating both barrera and morales in their primes, and indeed got a win over a past-prime barrera. his accomplishments at lightweight also put him high in the list, and he was evenly matched with pac when they were at 126 and 130. so my rankings are:

1. Pac
2. Marquez
3. Barrera
4. Morales

it feels crazy to put morales so low, and on another day my bottom 3 might be shuffled around, but that's how i see it right now

[joelab75]

Manny
Barrera
Morales
JMM

i dont see JMM beating a prime Barrera in any weight.