Who is the most overrated?

[Bring It On]

neither are overrated except by their hardcore fans. They are both quality fighters who are very talented, even if they do have their weaknesses.

This is the correct answer.

[ts33]

neither's overrated.

khan is underrated because of his chin. he beats both bradley and alexander with ease imo. That jab, hand and footspeed, boxing skills and height and reach advantage mean no jww can touch him.

A lot of people forget that all three of his last opponents are 140 lbers - Malignaggi, salita and kotelnik. All three were solid boxers, and khan shut them out. If he fights JMM next, ill be a bit disappointed, but JMM is a very good fighter, and he'll certainly be more competitive at 140 than he was at 147 (and even that was against one of the top 2 fighters in the world)

I'd like to see him in there with the top guys, and i honestly think next year he'll fight at least two of the top jwws

[The Hammer]

Neither Bute nor Khan are overrated.

At 140 Bradley is overrated, and at 168 Ward is.

[King Ju-Ju]

Why isn't "Future P4P King" Devon Alexander in the poll?

Alexander is a fraud.

Kotelnik clearly beat him and got robbed. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a ******ed crackhead.

what else can u expect from a ****** ****** from europe.

[King Ju-Ju]

Neither Bute nor Khan are overrated.

At 140 Bradley is overrated, and at 168 Ward is.

agree with bradley but i kinda like ward. well actually i dont like ward but i think he is pretty good. his fighting style is kinda sucky 2 me but w.e. it gfets the job done.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Both are very skilled fighters. Bute is probably being slightly overrated right now. Hes benefitting from not being in the Super 6 and facing crude sluggers like Andrade and Miranda. Hes looked spectacular beating them but I need to see him against a couple of the Super 6 before I christen him the best at 168 like a lot of people have.

[Steak]

Neither Bute nor Khan are overrated.

At 140 Bradley is overrated, and at 168 Ward is.

neither of these guys are overrated either. Bradley is the most consistant performer at of all the guys at 140lbs, although I dont have a problem with anyone calling Khan the best at 140lbs. Bradley is definitely #2 in that case though.

and how is Ward overrated when he convincingly beat Kessler? hes the only one at 168 with a dominant win over a top 5 fighter. His wins over Miranda and Green arent terrible either.

[steeluv]

Khan clearly won, but it wasn't a shutout. Kotelnik came on strong late and won some rounds. I think he would do much better in a rematch. There is no shame in losing to the best JWW Khan. Kotelnik is the only man to beat Maidana. He clearly beat Alexander and also beat Prime Witter and got robbed. Alexander and Witter both got bullshit hometown gift decisions.

Top 5 at 140:

1. Khan
2. Kotelnik
3. Bradley
4. Maidana
5. Alexander

Kotelnik only won 2 rounds against Khan the most you can argue if u give VERY BIASED for Kotelnik is 4 rounds, the other Six Rounds were total Khan domination not even the Kotelnik's best friend would give him those rounds.