You know whats funny about the first Mayweather-Castillo fight?

[RubenSonny]

115-113 Castillo first fight...114-114 worst case scenario.

115-113 Mayweather second fight. 114-114 worst case scenario again.

but even so...Castillo should've won that first fight.

that 116-111 judge was pathetically wrong.

judge: Ken Morita 115-113
judge: Larry O'Connell 116-113
judge: Daniel Van de Wiele 115-113
Harold Lederman - 115-113
Larry Merchant - 115-113

you're right. 115-113 is a blowout.
I saw the fight and even with my amateur scoring skills agreed with the 115-113 score.

Interesting how you pick when the judges scores are valid or not valid....isnt it?

[NesNY]

Interesting how you pick when the judges scores are valid or not valid....isnt it?

I'm sure you agree with the judges in every Mayweather fight.


I get a pen/pad, watch the fight...tally scores and that's it. I only have the camera angles, I'm no pro judge, and I score it as objectively as possible.

It is what it is, bro. I don't get **** from saying Mayweather lost the fight. I didn't earn a penny, he's not my favorite boxer, nothing...i get nothing.

But he lost. big ****.

[Megamasterking]

I'm sure you agree with the judges in every Mayweather fight.


I get a pen/pad, watch the fight...tally scores and that's it. I only have the camera angles, I'm no pro judge, and I score it as objectively as possible.

It is what it is, bro. I don't get **** from saying Mayweather lost the fight. I didn't earn a penny, he's not my favorite boxer, nothing...i get nothing.

But he lost. big ****.

Don't even respond to that rubensonnny, he always looking for trouble... on the internet !

[NesNY]

Don't even respond to that rubensonnny, he always looking for trouble... on the internet !

lol.

come on now. I'm almost 30 yrs old. internet thuggery is for kids half my age.

if your feelings were hurt over the internet, you need thicker skin. I stop arguing as soon as I realize I'm starting to give a **** about an Internet argument.

[Calilloyd]

you're only allowed to use CompuBox to argue for Mayweather WINNING, not losing.

you already know this. CompuBox means nothing here since Floyd lost the statistical fight (and the real fight).

So that means Pacquiao lost to Marquez. Punch stats right?

[NesNY]

So that means Pacquiao lost to Marquez. Punch stats right?

again, you can only use CompuBox to credit Floyd (or by default, to discredit Manny Pacquiao). This is NSB, after all.

so yes, Manny lost the fight (first fight).

I thought the 10-6 rd made the difference, but a draw was a good decision. Manny saved his ass by knocking JMM down 3 times, before getting thoroughly outclassed for about 7 or 8 rounds.

He would've lost the 2nd fight as well, but the knockdown saved his ass again. Manny's been outboxed by a hall of famer, master counter-puncher in/near his prime twice. But he's also knocked down said Hall of famer 4 times to the canvas.

[Franco2012]

115-113 Castillo first fight...114-114 worst case scenario.

115-113 Mayweather second fight. 114-114 worst case scenario again.

but even so...Castillo should've won that first fight.

that 116-111 judge was pathetically wrong.

Exactly


Only dumb *****s thinks that second fight is one sided beat down.

I dont know where they got that from cuz nothing was one sided.I

In rematch Castillo was ahead on scorecards after round 9,but he gassed out last 3 rounds.

[Calilloyd]

I

again, you can only use CompuBox to credit Floyd (or by default, to discredit Manny Pacquiao). This is NSB, after all.

so yes, Manny lost the fight.

I thought the 10-6 rd made the difference, but a draw was a good decision. Manny saved his ass by knocking JMM down 3 times, before getting thoroughly outclassed for about 7 or 8 rounds.

I personally never use compu box to score a fight. It's not an exact science and it's subject to human error. If you rely on that you can't score a fight on your own. I'm just pointing out your double standard and you made it easy to do. LOL.

[RubenSonny]

I'm sure you agree with the judges in every Mayweather fight.


I get a pen/pad, watch the fight...tally scores and that's it. I only have the camera angles, I'm no pro judge, and I score it as objectively as possible.

It is what it is, bro. I don't get **** from saying Mayweather lost the fight. I didn't earn a penny, he's not my favorite boxer, nothing...i get nothing.

But he lost. big ****.

Okay I spotted a contradiction in your posts and you cant respond properly.

Don't even respond to that rubensonnny, he always looking for trouble... on the internet !

How am I always looking for trouble on the internet, its not my fault you lie about your age and claim your some kind of expert when your an idiot.

lol.

come on now. I'm almost 30 yrs old. internet thuggery is for kids half my age.

if your feelings were hurt over the internet, you need thicker skin. I stop arguing as soon as I realize I'm starting to give a **** about an Internet argument.

Is this post aimed at me? If it is pleace explain my internet thuggery.

[hugh grant]

I thoiught castillo won it quite clearly. But the thing is i dont know who was doing the commentary when i watched the fight. But they all clearly thought Castillo won, and were expecting his arm to raised in victory.