Look at The This "The Ring Magazine" Rankings - WTF?

[dyu]

WelterWeight
1.Manny Pacquiao 51-3-2(38KOs) WBO
2.Floyd Mayweather 41-0-0(25KOs)
3.Miguel Cotto 35-2-0(28KOs)
4.Andre Berto 26-0-0(20KOs) WBC
5.Shane Mosley 46-6-0(39KOs)
6.Joshua Clottey 35-4-0(20KOs)
7.Luis Collazo 30-4-0(15KOs)
8.Jan Zaveck 27-1-0(15KOs)IBF
9.Vyacheslav Senchenko 30-0-0(20KOs) WBA
10.Mike Jones 22-0-0(18KOs)

Logical.
I dunno how they rank floyd above manny on welter when manny is ranked higher on p4p.

[Pacquiao'd]

get em, Floyd and sergio.

cintron, donaire and bradely? wtf? other than that, the list is pretty good. and i dont know why pac is still sitting as the top 140lber when hes not fighting there

floyd should be P4P1. sergio def should be ahead of Pwill

[KickAzz]

Can they get any worst?

point out exactly what it is you don't agree with.

[Chups]

The problem with the list is that the casual boxing fan is going to take it as gospel truth. If you're going to make a rankings list, you should at least make it accurate. Especially if you're a professional publication like Ring Magazine is. I dunno, maybe I'm just a stickler for integrity in journalism.

The Ring rarely makes sudden moves because of 1 fight. It takes time to get to the list but so does falling out of it. Critics complain about how or why Mosley or Bernard is still there because they lost a fight. But fails to realize nobody else can beat them. For example, they complained about why Bernard is still on the list coz he lost to Joe....then he wins against an unbeaten Pavlik. Had the Ring taken him out....the critics would complain to put him back in.


Mosley should still be there....he went against a higher P4Per, he will not be beaten by anybody else unless your name is Floyd or Pac.

[Chups]

Logical.
I dunno how they rank floyd above manny on welter when manny is ranked higher on p4p.

Because Manny is also the Junior Welterweight Champ.

[F l i c k e r]

Well, if Donaire beats Montiel, I expect all you Donaire haters to jump bandwagon.

Already expecting it. Just throwing it out there.

[manok uli]

WelterWeight
1.Manny Pacquiao 51-3-2(38KOs) WBO
2.Floyd Mayweather 41-0-0(25KOs)
3.Miguel Cotto 35-2-0(28KOs)
4.Andre Berto 26-0-0(20KOs) WBC
5.Shane Mosley 46-6-0(39KOs)
6.Joshua Clottey 35-4-0(20KOs)
7.Luis Collazo 30-4-0(15KOs)
8.Jan Zaveck 27-1-0(15KOs)IBF
9.Vyacheslav Senchenko 30-0-0(20KOs) WBA
10.Mike Jones 22-0-0(18KOs)


Super WelterWeight
1.Sergio Martinez 45-2-2(24KOs)
2.Sergei Dzindziruk 37-0-0(23KOs) WBO
3.Cory Spinks 37-5-0(11KOs) IBF
4.Paul Williams 39-1-0(27KOs)
5.Miguel Cotto 35-2-0(28KOs) WBA
6.Kermit Cintron 32-3-1(28KOs)
7.Alfredo Angulo 18-1-0(15KOs)
8.Sechew Powell 26-2-0(15KOs)
9.Vanes Martirosyan 28-0-0(17KOs)
10.Yury Foreman 28-1-0(8KOs)


Top 10 P4P
1.Manny Pacquaio
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Wladimir klitschko
4.Juan Manuel Marquez
5.Ivan Calderon
6.Sergio Martinez
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Paul Williams
9.Shane Mosley
10.Chad Dawson

Heres the first flaw. You rank Williams higher than Cotto in SuperWelter but rank Cotto higher P4P.