Prime for Prime: Who is more skilled- Judah or Pacquiao?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I was discussing this in a PM. Just want to get the boards thoughts.

[Pretty Boy32 *]

Judah allday.

[AntDawg]

I'd say Pacquiao only because Judah always seemed to struggle with guys he should have had no problem beating.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I'd say Pacquiao only because Judah always seemed to struggle with guys he should have had no problem beating.

In his prime??

I think he was in his prime vs. Baldomir but I think it was more a focus and mental issue.

[Bushbaby]

C'mon Burner,are U serious??Why would U put Judah in the same sentence as the Pacman?!!

[jri9d0]

Manny, even a prime Judah had problems in championship rounds where Manny was still turning on the heat.

[AntDawg]

In his prime??

I think he was in his prime vs. Baldomir but I think it was more a focus and mental issue.

Didn't he struggle to beat a 37 old journey man before?

[Pacquiao'd]

burner, i think you should have bolded, circled and underlined SKILL so people understand the question...even though you cant

people are going to throw heart, stamina, focus and all the above into it

[-PANDA-]

I'd say Pacquiao only because Judah always seemed to struggle with guys he should have had no problem beating.

that doesnt make pacquiao more skilled, it wasnt a lack of skill that got him those losses, in fact judah gave every opponent he ever lost to hell:

tszyu: beat him up in the first round of that fight before getting chin checked in the second round for being ****y
spinks: brutally KO'd him their rematch
baldomir: lost a close decision for not doing anything in that fight
mayweather: gave mayweather hell for 6 rounds and even knocked him down
cotto: seriously hurt him 3 times before folding due to the fouls
clottey: very close fight, clottey couldnt have won it by more than a point cuz judah was outboxing him in a lot of those rounds

Manny, even a prime Judah had problems in championship rounds where Manny was still turning on the heat.

judah fights for 6 rounds in a 12 round fight, pac gets hit repeatedly with right hands he just takes the shots better and hes faster and more powerful not more skilled

[Carpe Diem]

Judah..Is this even a question?