Is Fernando Montiel an ATG?

[SNVDoublePunch!]

After winning a unification match against an excellent champion in his own third championship division, I have to have him on the radar. Anybody here thinking of him as an ATG or at least potential ATG? The win over Hasegawa actually surprised me and made me look over his body of work seriously. He's 16-2 in major world title fights across three weight classes and has defeated nine world champions. What do you think? If a definite no, what would or could he do to get there, in your opinion?

[BoxerDood]

No he isn't an ATG right now, but wins over Morel and Donaire would probably make him top 5 p4p. Who knows what can happen from there.

[SNVDoublePunch!]

Mm, yes, Donaire VS Montiel would be good for boxing. I hope Montiel beats the hell out of that sex offender, Morel too.

[SNVDoublePunch!]

Come on, people.

[BOLLOCKS]

Montiel > JMM

[ManOfVictory]

Montiel > JMM

not yet!

[SNVDoublePunch!]

Montiel > JMM

Hmm. Bold statement.

[check hook]

After winning a unification match against an excellent champion in his own third championship division, I have to have him on the radar. Anybody here thinking of him as an ATG or at least potential ATG? The win over Hasegawa actually surprised me and made me look over his body of work seriously. He's 16-2 in major world title fights across three weight classes and has defeated nine world champions. What do you think? If a definite no, what would or could he do to get there, in your opinion?

no. not even close yet, but the win over Hasegawa was excellent. He needs more notches on his belt. If he gets a few more wins against top opposition expect to see him in P4P calculations.

[NORMAN BLACK]

NOPE!!! and he will not BE!

[SNVDoublePunch!]

17-2 now.