Is Roger overrated as a trainer?

[Deevel916]

Lets think about this. Who has he turned into a world champ? Floyd Jr was trained and taught by his dad up until he won the WBC SFW title. Floyd Sr turned him into a champ and the fighter he is today. Not Roger. Even during Floyd's fights, I never hear Roger give Floyd any knowlegeable advice. "pot shot that mofo" ..."His ass gonna get tired, and that's when we'll get his ass"....."Just keep doing what u doing, that mofo aint ****".

[pistol whip]

Does Roger even train anyone else that has done anything remotely worth wild in the sport?

[NECK SNAPPER]

Roger has done a great job with little floyd.
No question man man has done his job.i dont know about training anyone else

[Doctor_Tenma]

He's not really rated that high as a trainer, so I don't understand this thread.

[Vito Corleone]

How can Roger be overrated when he isn't even "rated"?

Think about this: Jack Mosley has TWO trainer of the year awards. What has Jack done in the pro ranks that Roger has not?

[da beatdown]

I think he is cuz he doesnt have a stable of boxers but as far as him not giving floyd detailed instruction, does he really have to? Floyd's never in need for it.

[Deevel916]

Roger has done a great job with little floyd.
No question man man has done his job.i dont know about training anyone else

Floyd was already great when Roger took over for Floyd Sr. That's my point.

[Shabba Rank$]

Well he's not really rated as a trainer man...

[infamous larryx]

roger is a world class trainer..do you know how much knowlege you have to have to train at that level???floyds blessed with a great boxing brain which makes rogers job easier..but you dont see what he does behind the scenes..

[Shabba Rank$]

roger is a world class trainer..do you know how much knowlege you have to have to train at that level???floyds blessed with a great boxing brain which makes rogers job easier..but you dont see what he does behind the scenes..

He trains other people at the Mayweather gym?