Floyd would UD Calzaghe 12-0

[Rosseboi]

Imagine Floyd with all the skills and speed he has....at 168. Also the same height and weight as Joe.

Vs. Calzaghe.

P4P: All things equal. Saying that if they were the same size.

I thought this was common knowledge.

Sorry mate but based on where reference the general census for P4P is one of two things:

1) It's accomplishment based - ie: how many belts a guy gets or the weight divisions a fighter dominates and basically just how kick ass he is compared to the next guy etc. This seems to be the scale used in many arguments for or against manny or Floyd as P4P no 1.

2) (my preference) scaled skill comparison. Eg if a fighter is scaled up or down in size proportionally could they beat the next guy. the thing to remember here is speed; peeps slow down the bigger they get, footwork drops off, mobility etc which makes it very subjective.


No Ceiling. i respect ya brother but Floyd is MUCH slower than he was back in the day @ a lower weight so your basis for the 168 comparison is big time flawed bro

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I'd expect Mayweather to knock out Calzaghe at 160lbs as Joe would be a raisin.

P4P, Calzaghe is probably better than anyone Mayweather has ever fought. So how he "wins every round", I dont know...

[handwraps]

Floyd doesn't have the frame to fight at the same weight as Joe, it just wouldn't happen.

even if it did floyd would have problems too manypunches from too many angles and matches his speed floyd would lose.

[boxasmash]

Calzaghe wins p4p, forget at 168.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Sorry mate but based on where reference the general census for P4P is one of two things:

1) It's accomplishment based - ie: how many belts a guy gets or the weight divisions a fighter dominates and basically just how kick ass he is compared to the next guy etc. This seems to be the scale used in many arguments for or against manny or Floyd as P4P no 1.

2) (my preference) scaled skill comparison. Eg if a fighter is scaled up or down in size proportionally could they beat the next guy. the thing to remember here is speed; peeps slow down the bigger they get, footwork drops off, mobility etc which makes it very subjective.


No Ceiling. i respect ya brother but Floyd is MUCH slower than he was back in the day @ a lower weight so your basis for the 168 comparison is big time flawed bro

Not true sir.

The Point of a P4P fight is to leave Floyd with the EXACT skill, movement and skills that he has now but in a 168 pound body.

He'd shut Calzaghe out and make him look like a fool.

[boxingking500]

im dead serious.. even @ 160.

yes... of course

floyd can also defeat wladimir klitschko

walk on water
create pocket universes with his mind
transform into a tiger
turn coke into pepsi..
etc. etc.

i mean come on its floyd mayweather.. hell you know in ***** mythology mayweather= GOD.... theres stories of him doing all kinds of stuff... dont believe it... well your just a non-believer then.......

so shut up losers... floyd is the best....... he can beat any boxers currently alive, GOAT.... he would knock anybody out with 1 punch... its floyd mayweather people.... hes number #1

[Earl-Hickey]

Lol yeah ok then, im not even sure Floyd could beat Williams @ 154

[RimmyDelicious]

Calzaghe wins p4p, forget at 168.

this.

Super Joe is still underrated.

[Earl-Hickey]

Not true sir.

The Point of a P4P fight is to leave Floyd with the EXACT skill, movement and skills that he has now but in a 168 pound body.

He'd shut Calzaghe out and make him look like a fool.

So what would a 6 foot 7 250lb Floyd with the same skill, movement and skills that he has now do to the klitschkos?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

So what would a 6 foot 7 250lb Floyd with the same skill, movement and skills that he has now do to the klitschkos?

Not fight them